How “social anti-dumping” Directive that Macron came up with could be: Small impact, incomprehensible high pressure from Western Europe

de Mariana Bechir | 25.9.2017 .

Member states are trying to reach a consensus by October about the European Commission’s proposals to amend the European Directive on posted workers.

Although it is a new subject dividing the European Union (Western Europe and the former communist states have divergent positions), it has a minor impact on the labour market, according to an analysis of the Bruegel think tank in Brussels.

The reform became known to the EU citizens only after the French president, Emmanuel Macron, made a tour in the eastern bloc this summer, including Bucharest, to try to secure the reform of the system for posted workers.

Central and Eastern European states reject the amendments, though. The only concession that they are willing to accept would be to support the proposals if shaped in an attenuated form, but with a condition – that carriers would not fall under this directive.

Current situation, which Western states want to change

Posted workers are employed in a country (country of origin) and sent to work for different periods in another country. They pay taxes in the country of origin and generally are subject to the labour law in their country of origin.

The employer is not required to pay the posted worker more than the minimum wage established by the host country.

The host country’s legal regime also applies to working time, minimum rest time, paid leave, minimum wage, workplace, health, as well as work protection, safety and hygiene measures.

Example: A firm in Romania gets a contract for building a construction in Paris. Employees will pay taxes and contributions, and their salaries are, even though higher than in Romania, well below those of local workers.

The current provisions date back to 1996 when the pay gap within the EU was not so high. Meanwhile, poorer countries have also become members, such as Romania and Bulgaria, and old member states, such as Spain, have faced big labour market problems.

In these 21 years, the economic and labour market situation in the European Union has considerably changed, and the Commission has found that some firms have benefited from the widening wage gaps and have used the system as a way to benefit from these gaps.

How European Commission wants this directive to be


The current Directive only stipulates that posted workers are entitled to the minimum wage in the host country. The new proposal provides for the application of the same rules on remuneration in the host member state as laid down by law or by collective agreements of general application.

That does not mean equal pay.

Remuneration does not only include the minimum wage but also other elements such as bonuses (for holidays, for example), allowances or wage increases based on seniority.

Member states will have the obligation to transparently state the various elements that form the remuneration on their territory. If they are laid down by law or collective agreements of general application, these elements will have to be considered in determining the salaries of posted workers.


A worker posted to the construction sector in Belgium must be granted, in addition to the minimum wage for his category (which varies from EUR 13.379 / hour to EUR 19.319), a number of remuneration elements laid down in the collective agreement of general application for the construction sector:

  • compensation for adverse weather conditions;
  • mobility allowance;
  • additional payment for executing special works;
  • allowances for tool depreciation, etc.

Long-term posting

The Commission also proposes that workers posted for more than two years (long-term posting) should at least be under the labour protection compulsory rules from the host member state.

This measure will apply right from the first day if it can be anticipated that workers will be posted for more than 24 months. In all other cases, the measure will apply as soon as the posting duration exceeds 24 months.


Workers posted to Germany for more than two years will benefit from the rules in that country on the protection against abusive dismissal, even though the labour law in their country of origin does not provide for such protection.

Collective agreements of general application

The Commission proposes that the rules laid down in collective agreements of a general application become mandatory for posted workers in all economic sectors.

Subcontracting chains

Within the subcontracting chains, member states will have the option of applying in the case of posted workers the same pay rules that are compulsory for the main contractor, even if these rules result from collective agreements with no general application.

Position of member states

Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg, the Netherlands and Sweden (host countries with large numbers of posted workers from poorer countries)

They want for the principle of “equal pay for the same work” to be accepted and invoke two arguments:

  • significant wage gaps distort the conditions of fair competition between businesses, thus undermining the good functioning of the single market
  • social dumping caused by posted workers who are much cheaper than local workers (posted workers earn up to 50% less than local workers in certain sectors and member states).

Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Lithuania, Latvia, Poland, Slovakia and Romania (suppliers of cheap posted workers) are against reforming the system and ask at least a compromise, to exclude the transport sector.

Poland is the most interested in getting these exemptions, as 30,000 companies would be affected, with a total of 300,000 drivers.

Romania: situation and position

Romanian companies had 46,871 workers posted in different EU states in 2015, according to the European Commission data.

Most of them worked in construction (40.7%), manufacturing industry (38.3%), business services (7.3%) and transport (5.5%).

Current situation in EU

In 2015 there were 2.05 million posted workers in the EU, following an accelerated growth by 41.3% compared to 2010.

Host countries with the largest number of posted workers are Germany (28% of the total – 420,000 people), France (11,9%) and Belgium (10,5%):


  • Ranking of countries that host posted workers
  • Source:


Poland (22.8% – over 450.000 people), Germany (11.7%) and France (6.9%) stand out in the ranking of countries supplying posted workers.


  • Ranking of countries supplying posted workers
  • Source:


In relation to local employment, though, Luxembourg (with 9% of the total number of posted workers), Belgium (3.8%) and Austria (2.5%) are the countries where posted workers register the highest percentages.

Why impact on labour market will be low

According to an analysis of the Bruegel think tank, the impact on the labour market will be modest.

Main arguments:

Seconded workers represent only 0.9% of all employees in the EU 28, which means only 0.2% in full-time equivalents. The average period during which workers are posted and provide services in another country is less than four months. On average, a worker is posted 1.9 times a year. The two million workers posted per year represent a small part of the overall mobility registered in the EU, where there are 11.3 million long-term migrant Europeans in another member state.

Estimates show that the shorter the periods of posting are, the lower the impact is. In Germany, 4.5% of construction workers are posted workers but the impact is lower as 90% of them are seconded for periods of up to six months.

Also, the Bruegel think tank notes, it is a false assumption that posted workers come mostly from countries with low wages. In fact, according to the analysis, postings from a low-wage country to one with high wages account for a third in total, the same as the number of posted workers from a country with high salaries to another country with high salaries.

The most suggestive example is France, which wants a tougher wording of the directive than the version proposed by the EC and where only 23% of posted workers come from low-wage countries, while 44% of the posted workers it hosts come from countries with a high pay. The same is in Belgium – 58% are citizens of countries with high incomes:


Publicat la data de 25.9.2017 .

Lasa un comentariu


Marin Pana

Advance of real wage – a list of anomalies: Administration exceeds health domain by 44%, manufacturing sector drops to less than 90% of economy average

The average gross salary announced by INS for August 2017 was 3,290 lei, by 12% higher than in the previous month The net average wage was 2,364 lei, or 514 euros at the average exchange rate of September 2017 (the actual month of payment) or 1,004 euros in terms of purchasing power at the EU average prices Compared to the reference month of October 1990, the real monthly earning index ...
Read more »

Victor Bratu

Split VAT: What does not Government want to see in VAT fraud and why it has a different definition for the VAT gap than the European Commission

When it comes to the "VAT gap", the Romanian Government and the European Commission have different views on the elements contributing to this indicator Even different definitions The difference between the Government's approach and the Commission’s approach sets out two versions, both having an impact on the business environment, which is required to apply the split VAT: either the split ...
Read more »

Victor Bratu

Analysis person by person: Government members who decided on split VAT and protect their own companies of VAT split

Photo caption: Prime Minister Mihai Tudose publicly supports split VAT but the company in which he has declared interests does not support Mihai Tudose In the democracy, the power of example is a way often used by state officials to demonstrate the fairness of the decisions assumed We do not see too often that happening in Romania, nor does it happen in the specific case of the changes ...
Read more »

Mariana Bechir

Romania could become the only EU country where social contributions are paid only by employees

If the PSD-ALDE alliance does not reconsider the measure of transferring all social contributions to the employees, Romania will be the first EU country where employers will no longer contribute to financing the social security system In the table below, it is noted that all EU member states have divided this burden between the employer and the employee, and in most cases, the contributions ...
Read more »

Razvan Diaconu

BNR: Arguments of a monetary policy concession to government policy errors

BNR decided on Tuesday to narrow the "symmetrical corridor" between the interest rates of the standing facilities around the monetary policy rate (175%, unchanged), by increasing the deposit interest rate and lowering the Lombard rate At the same time, BNR also injected liquidity on the money market amounted to more than RON 9 billion by repo-type operations, buying government bonds from ...
Read more »


European Commission’s announcement to Government and Parliament: Gas transactions market cannot be monopolized by OPCOM

Romania risks the infringement procedure if the Parliament adopts definitive amendments to the Emergency Ordinance 64/2017 on the natural gas market, which provides for the ... Read more

Ministry of Finance has sold euro bonds worth one billion euros on foreign market

The Ministry of Finance (MFP) placed euro bonds worth EUR 1 billion on the foreign market by reopening the issue with the maturity of 10 ... Read more

Ford launches production of EcoSport in Craiova. Total investment in Romania reaches over EUR 1.2 billion

Ford officially launched the production of the EcoSport SUV at the plant in Craiova, raising total investments in Romania to about EUR 1.2 billion, since ... Read more

VAT Directive - Reform plan: European Commission proposes to abolish zero rate on cross-border purchases

Pierre Moscovici, the European Commissioner for Economic and Financial Affairs, Taxation and Customs, announced on Wednesday in Brussels the proposals of the European Commission for ... Read more

Total political control: Deputy Iulian Iancu insists on offering monopoly to OPCOM on gas trading

OPCOM will have a monopoly on the operation of centralized natural gas markets, and producers will be required to trade, as of January 1, 2018, ... Read more

Romania - world champion of frontier markets in 2017, by return on stock exchange investment

Evolution of BET-TR since the beginning of the year The Romanian capital market had the highest growth among all 23 countries in the portfolio of ... Read more

Investment of the poor: MFP sells one-lei treasury bonds to population and money will be blocked until maturity

The Ministry of Public Finance (MFP) wants to raise money to the budget, leu by leu and says that treasury bills, whose issues have already ... Read more

Strong warning from European Commissioner for Energy: Regulators must be completely independent. BRUA continues

The European Commission monitors the real independence of the regulators in the member states and will take all necessary steps to ensure that it is ... Read more

China's sovereign wealth fund, owner of four logistics parks in Romania

The European Commission has approved the EUR 12 billion deal by which China Investment Corporation, China’s sovereign wealth fund, has taken over the assets of ... Read more

Transelectrica announces that it lends money for investments after Government seized its financial reserves

The national energy system operator, Transelectrica, a state-owned company operating the National Energy System (SEN), tells shareholders that the distribution of additional ROL 171 million ... Read more

Oracle transfers most of its European hardware support activities to Romania

Oracle, the world’s largest software developer, will transfer most of the European hardware support activities to Romania, to reduce current costs. The process of closing ... Read more

LSE Study: Ten Romanian companies can inspire Europe with their rhythm of growth. Meanings of this selection

London Stock Exchange (LSE) analysts have identified ten Romanian companies among the 1,000 small and mid-sized firms in Europe that can inspire the others with ... Read more

Eastern European countries’ exports of weapons increase. Not Romania’s ones

Producers of bullets, assault weapons, and rockets from former communist countries in Eastern Europe saw a significant increase in orders following the conflicts in the ... Read more

European Commissioner: Brexit will decrease budget for Regional Policy by 10-12%. Member states will have to cover these amounts

The budget allocated by the EU to the Regional Policy will decrease by approximately 10-12% after the exit of the UK from the Union, said ... Read more

Government prepares to guarantee unchanged royalty regime throughout offshore concession contracts

The Government is trying to speed up the implementation of the offshore oil operations. There is a bill at SGG that assures companies having oil ... Read more

Consultations on security topics between Poland, Romania and Turkey with participation of Jens Stoltenberg

Preparations for the NATO Summit in 2018 and the reform of the allied command structures were the main topics for the last week’s meeting, on ... Read more

Representatives of prosecutors across the country reject Minister's proposals to amend justice laws

Representatives of prosecutors from all over the country have rejected amendments to the justice laws proposed by Minister Tudorel Toader, General Prosecutor Augustin Lazar said ... Read more

Average monthly spending per household in 2016: Education - 4 lei, Telephone services - 90 lei

Last year, a household spent a monthly average of 4.05 lei for education, 90.71 lei for telephone services and 26.26 lei for health services, according ... Read more

Cost of state indebtedness rises and drags euro exchange rate with it

Government’s hunger for money causes a growing demand on the market, which increases the borrowing cost for the state and encourages distrust in the national ... Read more

Mihai Tudose about royalties: A new law to enter into force on January 1, 2018; royalty level will "depend on companies’ behaviour" in terms of prices pushed by the new excise duty

Prime Minister Mihai Tudose has announced the date of January 1, 2018, as a “certain” term for the entry into force of a long-delayed new ... Read more

File / Share of French investments in Romanian industry decreased compared to 2007. Investment in agriculture and utilities increased

The share of direct investment (FDI) made by French companies in the Romanian industry fell from 56% of total French FDI in 2007 to 46% ... Read more

Prime Minister Mihai Tudose - threats and warnings to banks and oil companies: Romantic period has passed

Prime Minister Mihai Tudose has released several strong signals to banks and oil companies. He says that he is willing to take major risks in ... Read more

MApN states its availability to buy US attack helicopters

Defence Minister Adrian Tutuianu has signed on Wednesday a letter of intent on price and availability regarding the purchase of attack helicopters produced by Bell ... Read more

Minister Ionut Misa: Salary growth to increase public pension fund deficit by 22% in 2018 compared to 2017

The deficit of the public pension fund would be 17.2 billion lei in 2018, up 22% from 14.1 billion lei this year because of the ... Read more