SIMILAR ARTICLES

Prime Minister Dancila dismissed 13 of 15 civil society representatives from Economic and Social Council. They were blocking legislation that did not gathered all opinions

Prime Minister Viorica Dancila has replaced 13 of the 15 civil society representatives in the Economic and Social Council (CES). Following a decision published on… Mai mult

Cluj-Napoca – only city in Romania that receives European funds for innovative projects

Only Cluj-Napoca is among the 22 European cities that will receive financing from the European Regional Development Fund (FEDR) for innovative solutions in addressing urban… Mai mult

West Quadrilateral / Four counties joined to directly access European money for major infrastructure projects

From right to left: Gheorghe Falca, Nicolae Robu, Ilie Bolojan. Emil Boc, Mayor of Cluj Napoca, misses Four mayors from the West of the country… Mai mult

Chamber of Deputies / PSD loses UDMR’s support for amending Offshore Law, draft returns to committees for a week

The plenum of the Chamber of Deputies decided on Wednesday to resend the Offshore Law to committees after a seemingly surprising request of UDMR leader… Mai mult

Romania ranked 7th in EU in terms of renewable electricity

Unlike the vast majority of the economic areas, in which we are at the bottom of the European ranking, Romania succeeded to rank 7th by… Mai mult

“Emergency constitutional support”: President Iohannis sends laws on judiciary to Venice Commission and asks Constitutional Court to wait for the answer

de Razvan Diaconu , 7.5.2018

President Klaus Iohannis announced on Wednesday that he is referring to the Constitutional Court of Romania the Parliament’s amendments to the three laws on the judiciary. He will also refer to the Venice Commission and publicly asked the Constitutional Court to wait for the Venice Commission’s answer and recommendations.

All these actions are intended to discontinue the promulgation procedure for the three laws, pending the Venice Commission response.

Its recommendations are not mandatory, but they will basically have to be respected, otherwise, there is a risk of reactions from Brussels. For example, the mechanism for assessing the rule of law could be triggered, as was the case with Poland.

With the present format of the package of amendments to these laws, it does not correspond to a democratic state, in the way the Constitution says in Article 1.

I, therefore, decided to send the whole package back to the Constitutional Court and, in parallel, to bring the matter to the Venice Commission.

That is why I appeal to the Constitutional Court not to hurry but work with the European body that has been contributing for almost 30 years to the development of a common constitutional patrimony in Europe and which supports states wishing to align legal and institutional structures to international standards and good practices in the fields of democracy, rule of law and protection of human rights, including by providing urgent constitutional support.

trust that judges of the Constitutional Court respect their status as guarantors of the supremacy of the Basic Law and defenders of democracy by law, so they will have all the openness towards an approach that aims to ensure the observance in Romania of the principles and values of the European democracy.

Once the Court has expressed its views on these matters, I shall make a new analysis of the laws and decide then whether a revision is necessary“, said Klaus Iohannis

President’s statements:

Let us remember how we got here. In the autumn of 2016, there was an electoral campaign for Parliament and PSD played the people with a milk and honey program and won the elections, but something totally different followed. The assault on the judiciary from the PSD started.

Then at the beginning of 2017, they came with that infamous OUG 13. That ordinance we managed to stop it together. Hundreds of thousands of Romanians in good faith protested in the street.

The assault has moved to the Parliament, and the outcome of the parliamentary move to amend the laws on the judiciary has now reached the point of the promulgation of these laws.

The original procedure, the rush without any justification and the authoritarian way in running the parliamentary debates resulted in a great deal of mistrust.

The reform of the judiciary, as called for by PSD, is still being challenged by the professional associations of magistrates and creates great concerns from our foreign partners.

In an authentic democracy, the separation of powers in the state means a constructive collaboration, respect among institutions, balance and mutual control between them. Laws on the judiciary have an important role. They have been adopted within a week. It took four months and three decisions of the Constitutional Court to correct them. Everybody would have won if they were debated in the right way.

I find that the three laws are not fully adequate either to the domestic constitutional framework or to the European standards in the field.

Provisions in the Law on the regulations of judges have been declared unconstitutional on two occasions. Some provisions are still contrary to the Constitution.

The law on the judicial organization has already come to promulgation but it still raises some issues. The new rules on the admission to the magistracy pose a risk of blocking the judiciary system. New structures have been created that could intimidate the magistrates.

Nor is the law on CSM having a happier wording. It establishes a segregation of the guarantor of the independence of the judiciary by a massive transfer from the CSM plenum to the sections, probably based on the “Divide et impera” principle.

The Venice Commission has already been notified on March 26 by the Monitoring Committee of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), following the request from PNL and the Judges’ Forum.

Initially, the head of state said he would not refer to the Venice Commission, but he has not explained his decision.

The three laws amended by PSD – ALDE:

  • Law 303/2004 on the regulations of judges
  • Law 304/2004 on the judicial organization
  • Law 317/2004 on the organization and functioning of CSM

After the second constitutional review, two of the three laws on the judiciary have been declared constitutional, and the provisions of Law 303/2004 on the regulations of judges declared unconstitutional will be discussed in the special parliamentary committee led by Florin Iordache, after the Constitutional Court publishes the reasons for this decision.

The two laws that have been declared constitutional are in the promulgation process and there is no possibility of suspending this procedure. According to the Constitution, the head of state is obliged to promulgate a law within 10 days since receiving the Constitutional Court decision, if there was a referral, and the judges of the Court considered it constitutional.

 

Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 7.5.2018

Lăsați un comentariu


NEWS

Cluj-Napoca - only city in Romania that receives European funds for innovative projects

Only Cluj-Napoca is among the 22 European cities that will receive financing from the European Regional Development Fund (FEDR) for innovative solutions in addressing urban… Mai mult

Prime Minister Dancila dismissed 13 of 15 civil society representatives from Economic and Social Council. They were blocking legislation that did not gathered all opinions

Prime Minister Viorica Dancila has replaced 13 of the 15 civil society representatives in the Economic and Social Council (CES). Following a decision published on… Mai mult

West Quadrilateral / Four counties joined to directly access European money for major infrastructure projects

From right to left: Gheorghe Falca, Nicolae Robu, Ilie Bolojan. Emil Boc, Mayor of Cluj Napoca, misses Four mayors from the West of the country… Mai mult

Chamber of Deputies / PSD loses UDMR’s support for amending Offshore Law, draft returns to committees for a week

The plenum of the Chamber of Deputies decided on Wednesday to resend the Offshore Law to committees after a seemingly surprising request of UDMR leader… Mai mult

Government amended insolvency law. Guarantees given by Minister Teodorovici

The Government adopted on Thursday the draft Emergency Ordinance for amending and supplementing legislation in the field of insolvency, which provides among other things for… Mai mult

Romania ranked 7th in EU in terms of renewable electricity

Unlike the vast majority of the economic areas, in which we are at the bottom of the European ranking, Romania succeeded to rank 7th by… Mai mult

Resounding failure of PSD lobbying action in Brussels

There are clear signs that the lobbying action launched by the ruling coalition in Brussels in favour of the government in Bucharest will end with… Mai mult

MFP: Romania does not endorse a separate budget for Eurozone and rejects the idea of ​​taxing financial transactions

Romania does not endorse a separate budget for Eurozone and rejects the idea of taxing financial transactions, Minister of Public Finance Eugen Teodorovici said after… Mai mult

Finance Ministry wants to change rules for insolvency: state could also register claims after procedure is launched

Companies’ possibility to avoid paying creditors (and in particular the payment of tax receivables) simply by declaring their insolvency would be drastically limited, according to… Mai mult

Phil Hogan: Swine fever in Romania has an impact on neighbouring countries and EU trade in pigs

Prime Minister Viorica Dancila, European Commissioner Phil Hogan and Agriculture Minister Petre Daea The swine fever epidemics in Romania has an impact on neighbouring countries,… Mai mult

Infrastructure projects lost EUR 41.5 million following budget amendment. In what projects cuts have been made

Despite the assurances that Dancila government is concerned and intensely working on the road infrastructure projects, at the budget amendment the Transport Ministry has cut… Mai mult

European Parliament have decided to adopt in October a resolution on the rule of law in Romania

Leaders of the political groups in the European Parliament have decided to adopt in October a resolution on the rule of law in Romania. The… Mai mult

"Romania's buffers have deteriorated, the country is less prepared for a negative shock" - IMF will reduce economic growth estimate

Romania will be less prepared if the economy is hit by a negative shock, as the structural deficit has been deteriorated - IMF representative for… Mai mult

Premiere: CSAT asks Finance Ministry to amend amendment - session suspended until Government comes with a draft that does not affect budgets of secret services

President Klaus Iohannis suspended on Tuesday the CSAT meeting for discussing the budget amendment, as there was no consensus on the budgets of institutions from… Mai mult