SIMILAR ARTICLES

Workforce crisis: Romania doubles “imports” of Asian workers

2017 was the first year when the share of foreign (third states) workers initially established – instead of 3,000 permanent workers, as estimated initially based… Mai mult

14 brave Franco-Germans relaunch the stake of the moment: six radical proposals for reforming Eurozone. “RON Romania” can meditate on solution

Given that the talks on the Eurozone reform held by the governments of France and Germany seem to get to no result, a possible solution… Mai mult

Romania loses an important indicator for accession to Eurozone. Explanation for (increased) difference between CPI and HICP

Romania recorded an annual inflation of 2.6% at the end of 2017, according to the data provided by Eurostat for all member states. We are… Mai mult

Already a (big) problem: The real negative interest rate. An evolution in deposits and loans

After entering the negative range at the mid of 2017, the remuneration of deposits at commercial banks reached a worrying -2.23% per year, according to… Mai mult

Lost opportunities: Romanian companies have not capitalized on years with low interest rates. Neither did banks. Causes

Romanian companies missed the opportunity window in recent years, of financing at low interest rates. They considered this opportunity only in the second half of… Mai mult

With what? Romania – for 10 years, last in EU by budget revenues and first to reduce them! Specific problems

de Marin Pana , 18.12.2017

Romania undertook, between 2006 and 2016, the most bizarre policy on public funds of all European countries, according to an analysis released by Eurostat. Starting from the last position in terms of the share of budget revenues in GDP, our country struggled hard last year to reduce them even further.

Only the massive relocation of some multinationals in little Ireland made us lose, under very special statistical circumstances, the position of a European red flashlight to which we would have been fully entitled to due to the utterly irresponsible strategy of permanent tax ease. A strategy based on which we shall ensure not the convergence but the divergence in relation to civilized Europe.

From a minus 10% of GDP in budget revenues from taxes and social contributions compared to the European average just before the EU accession, Romania has reached a disastrous -14% last year, after decreasing the revenue collection by three percentage points in the context of the increase in the overall average by one percentage point (see table).

*

  • Evolution of the share in budget revenues from taxes and social contributions in some EU countries (% GDP, 2006-2016)
  • Country

*

On this divergent trend in relation to the practice in the Western states that we want to catch up, the ratio of the money available to the Romanian state for health, education, administration, public order, social protection, etc. and the EU average (considering, of course, the proportion of GDP level) fell from 74% to only 65%.

It may seem a little to some people, but within ten years, the increase in the budget revenues needed for us to start on an equal footing with our counterparts that manage public funds has grown from + 35% (correct is the increase needed in taxes) to a fulminant + 54% in 2016. Make the ratio of 100% to 74% and then to 65% and see what result we obtain.

An important mention. Contrary to the established political clichés, the state, basically, does not takes or gives money, but redistributes it. From productive activity or consumption to the areas of which it is in charge (mentioned above) or from one to the other. If you wish, move some of the decision of money use from your personal pocket to the benefit of all.

A state that redistributes a little is inherently a weak state (not in terms of repression but the possibility to provide social services). Lacking the ability to perform at the level of Western societies to which we theoretically aspire, and do not quite agree when it comes to accurately translating them into practice. As we would translate from English, we should put the money where we put the words.

Specific issues: Possible and feasible solutions in European practice

Beyond the eternal and traditional lamentations about our situation, where we cannot do so much with so little, neither public policies without money, let’s look at others and see what we can do. We chose three countries: Spain (because it is Latin, somewhat similar and the only one besides Romania that is below the European average of revenue collection in all areas), Poland (because it comes from the eastern block and is closest to us in terms of the economy size, structure and level of development) and Germany (chosen as a benchmark for its optimized economic and social performance).

*

  • EU average
  • Tax on production
  • – of which VAT
  • Tax on income and wealth
  • households
  • – companies
  • Social contributions

*

If we are to compare the percentages to the European usage, we immediately see the source of problems in public budget financing. Even if we do not agree, we shall have to increase sometime, as soon as possible, taxes on households and social contributions. The dose of them could be of a Polish inspiration and commensurate with the level of the increase in living standards.

The Bulgarian alternative to this Spanish-Polish-German action would be to maintain the taxes mentioned at relatively low values and strongly push the tax on production and VAT (measuring, at the south of the Danube, 114% and 131%, respectively, of the EU average).

The fact that the second option does not seem to be for a long run, beyond our national appetite for VAT evasion, is explained by Germany’s positioning, not at all a Bulgarian one, which applied a strategy of reduced taxes on production (with the VAT collected positioned at the EU average) and boosted social contributions above the European average.

As well as the disguise of Poland, in terms of fiscal policy, as a kind of smaller Germany, by keeping the proportions between the level of development and the taxation share compared to the European average. A model to which our Latin cousins from Spain also get close, except for our unwillingness to have taxes applied at the personal level, which can be explained (interesting note: not as much at the household level but on the social contributions side).

Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 18.12.2017

Lăsați un comentariu


NEWS

Second largest bank in EU, BNP Paribas, opens its branch in Bucharest

BNP Paribas, the largest French bank and the second largest in the EU by the size of assets, will launch its retail operations in Romania… Mai mult

Three options by which BNR intends to moderate lending

The BNR will impose restrictions on credits to the population, to anticipate potential non-payment risks. This could happen in March if the project is approved… Mai mult

Siegfried Muresan: Amendments to Romanian laws on judicial will be discussed in European Parliament

The European Parliament will run debates on the situation of justice in Romania in the next plenary session, in February, in the Strasbourg plenary. The… Mai mult

State has initiated procedure for purchasing 51% of Daewoo's shares at Mangalia Shipyard

The Government approved in the last meeting a memorandum stating that the state will use its preemption right at Mangalia Shipyard and buy the 51%… Mai mult

First major acquisition in 2018 - MApN signs contract with General Dynamics to acquire 227 armoured carriers

Minister of National Defence, Mihai Fifor, participates Friday at the signing of the procurement contract for 227 Piranha V armoured carriers, a release of the… Mai mult

Business environment: Waiving governance rules in state-owned companies, another measure that deepens feeling of distrust

The Foreign Investors Council (FIC) released on Wednesday a statement that expresses its dissatisfaction with the "authorities’ political agenda" containing decisions that "will lead to… Mai mult

Bizarre government project Casa de Comert SA: name is booked since years ago at Trade Registry

Last week, the Ministry of Economy has launched to a public debate a draft government decision to establish the company Casa de Comert, which, according… Mai mult

Public Private Partnership: Government has regulated by emergency ordinance the cost cutting through "Value for Money" analysis

The Government has established the new regulations on the public-private partnership (PPP) by an emergency ordinance issued Thursday and introduced the Value for Money concept,… Mai mult

Catalin Ivan: In Romania, there are 384 companies with bearer shares, all collaborating with the state. More than EUR 40 billion transferred from Romania to offshore companies

MEP Catalin Ivan stated on Friday in Iasi that there are 384 companies with bearer shares in Romania, which gives the owners the comfort of… Mai mult

Brussels offers Romania four months to take measures to correct significant deviation of structural deficit

The European Council issued on Tuesday a new recommendation, at the request of the European Commission, based on the significant deviation procedure, with Romania being… Mai mult

Eurostat: Romania had second lowest tax to GDP ratio within EU, in 2016

In Romania, the ratio between the revenues that must be collected from taxes (including social contributions - tax/GDP ratio) and GDP was 26% in 2016,… Mai mult

9 ambassadors repeat: Venice Commission's opinion is needed to amend laws on judiciary

The nine ambassadors who met on Wednesday with Minister Tudorel Toader shared their "concern over the draft laws on the reform of the judiciary discussed… Mai mult

British Vitruvian Partners bought 30% of Bitdefender

Vitruvian Partners investment fund acquired about 30% of Bitdefender from Axxess Capital and becomes the second largest shareholder in the company, valued at over USD… Mai mult

Split VAT at the Chamber of Deputies: Dilemmas of all kinds. Thresholds for outstanding payments have increased 10 times, Budget Committee to resume debates on Monday

The Budget Committee of the Chamber of Deputies has increased ten times the threshold of the outstanding VAT obligations from which companies will automatically be… Mai mult

Competition Council: Food price increase could be caused by demand excess from budget deficit

The Competition Council started an analysis, following the request of the Ministry of Agriculture, to establish the causes of the accelerated food price increase this… Mai mult