SIMILAR ARTICLES

How Romania is seen from an EU economic indicators perspective

Eurostatistics is a synthesis based on a set of standardized and harmonized benchmarks for the comparability between countries at the European level (Principal European Economic… Mai mult

Quality of economic growth? Let’s look at resource productivity

Romania climbed last year on the penultimate position among the EU member states in terms of the productivity of resources in the economy, after Bulgaria,… Mai mult

Study: Consumption ghosts – Two-thirds of undercapitalised companies have no revenue

Romania’s economy is becoming more and more vulnerable due to the increasing number of businesses that state no revenues, register losses and debts exceeding their… Mai mult

Labour cost, more than 15% higher than last year

Hourly labour cost increased by 15.6% in the second quarter of 2018 compared to the same period of 2017 (+ 9.36%, compared to Q1 2018),… Mai mult

Fiscal Council, about budget amendment: Increase in revenues from VAT and excise duties has no basis

The Fiscal Council announced on Wednesday, the day when the Government adopted the draft budget amendment without the opinion from CSAT, that it considers the… Mai mult

All it takes against public money: Court of Auditors – mutilated and thrown at Administration’s feet. Commission warns that will suspend European funds

de Razvan Diaconu , 25.6.2018

The Senate, under its role as the decision-making chamber, in this case, will discuss in plenary amendments to Law 94/1992 on the functioning and organization of the Court of Auditors.

If senators keep the amendments approved by deputies, Romania risks the freezing of all payments for European financed projects in the current budget exercise.

In the European Commission’s view, some of the amendments approved in the lower chamber do not meet international standards and affect the institution’s independence.

In the initiators’ view, however, changes were made precisely to align the law with the international auditing standards. The correlation with the international regulations is the pretext invoked in the Explanatory Memorandum of this legislative intervention and of other bills harshly criticized by the European institutions. For example, the case of the “reform” of the laws on the judiciary.

Interventions on Law 94/1992 undoubtedly have the potential to severely affect the independence of the Court of Auditors in several ways:

  • extend the functions of the president (appointed by a political decision, by the Parliament) to the detriment of the collective management, through the Court’s plenary
  • allow the interference of other institutions in the Court ‘s activity
  • create loopholes for heads of public institutions who have illegally spent public money

For Romania, the stake of these amendments means over EUR 20 billion. For PSD and ALDE, the authors of the dangerous amendments, the stake is the political control of the Court of Auditors, so that local elected representatives and heads of institutions cannot be accountable for the unlawful or unnecessary spending of public (national and European) funds.

The draft amendment to Law 94/1992 on the Court of Auditors received a final vote in the Chamber of Deputies on 25 April and received all the opinions of the Senate committees involved in the proceeding.

Decision concentrated to only one hand: extending the role of the president, to the detriment of the Court of Auditors’ Plenary

The proposed amendments effectively annul the Court of Auditors’ collective management and the most important tasks are transferred from the plenary comprising 18 independent accountants to the president of the institution (a political figure appointed by the Parliament).

At this moment, the president is Mihai Busuioc (photo), a social-democrat loyal to Liviu Dragnea. Former Secretary-General of the Government, after PSD-ALDE came into power, he was the main pawn used by Liviu Dragnea inside Victoria Palace to prevent Sorin Grindeanu and Victor Ponta from taking over the Executive.

Mihai Busuioc was appointed to the Court of Auditors last year for a nine-year term.

Extended functions to the president:

  • “The organizational structure of the General Secretariat and the functions of its departments are established by the Plenary of the Court of Auditors,” the current law provides. The amendment voted by deputies adds that these things will be done following the proposal of the CC president.
  • It is the CC’s president who will decide whether he or she notifies prosecutors of the irregularities found. The fate of mayors, heads of institutions, etc. who spent the public money in violation of the law will exclusively depend on the will of a person who is a political appointee. At present, Article 33 says the notification is made by the head of the department who found “the existence of acts on which there are indications they were committed in violation of the law.”
  • The president approves the functions of departments and compartments within the General Secretariat and the President’s apparatus” will be added to Art. 60.
  • A new structure is established under the president’s authority – “President’s apparatus” (Article 8). It is a distinct structure from the general secretariat and the president’s office and will check all reports before they are transmitted.

Court of Auditors is no longer the supreme authority to certify data from implementation accounts verified

The draft approved in the Chamber of Deputies abrogated art. 31 of the current law, which now provides:

  • The Court of Auditors shall certify the accuracy and veracity of the data in the implementation accounts audited.
  • No other authority can issue an opinion on the data registered in the implementation accounts, except on a provisional basis.

This means that the CC is the decisive authority in the matter of discharge – the granting of the compliance certificate to certify the implementation of the accounts in a public authority.

By repealing the article, any entity may decide on the certification of public accounts and the Court of Auditors is obliged to accept the report of the auditor paid by the audited entity.

Measures to protect officials with criminal problems

  • It is repealed the CC’s obligation to request “the suspension from office, according to the law, of persons accused of committing acts causing significant damages or serious financial irregularities, ascertained during controls or audits, until the final settlement of the cases in which they are involved” (Article 45).
  • 54, which required the suspension of Court of Auditors members and external public auditors who are taken to court. The draft adopted by deputies provides for the suspension from office only when a conviction has been decided in a first instance.

Public Procurement Agency controls itself and findings become mandatory for Court of Auditors

According to an approved amendment, the Court of Auditors will be obliged to acknowledge all the findings made by the National Public Procurement Agency, a politically controlled institution under the Government’s authority. “Opinions expressed by the National Public Procurement Agency at the request of the Court of Auditors or when issuing their own control documents are mandatory“, states an amendment to Article 29 of the current law.

Similarly, it is stated that the audit Authority (from the Court of Auditors: checks how European funds are spent by institutions, public administrations, etc.).

Enforcing compliance with the findings of the Public Procurement Agency (ANAP) is bizarre, as there is a similar precedent that led to the suspension of payments for European projects in 2011.

The funds were then blocked precisely because of the ANAP’s involvement (more exactly, its predecessor, the National Authority for Regulating and Monitoring Public Procurement) in the management authorities’ activity, because the ANRMAP’s opinion was taken into consideration when the acquisitions were verified.

European Commission threatens to freeze European funds if Court of Auditors’ independence is affected

The European Commission sent the presidents of the two parliamentary chambers – Liviu Dragnea and Calin Popescu Tariceanu – a letter warning them that Romania risks the suspension of all payments on the European projects if the Court of Auditors is no longer independent.

In these letters, the European Commission asks the Parliament to cancel the proposed amendments to Law 94/1992, as they would endanger the independence of the audit Authority, informs G4Media.ro

Official warning letters were signed by representatives from three DGs: DG Regio, DG Competition and DG Mare (maritime affairs and fisheries).

Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 25.6.2018

Lăsați un comentariu


NEWS

Finance Ministry wants to change rules for insolvency: state could also register claims after procedure is launched

Companies’ possibility to avoid paying creditors (and in particular the payment of tax receivables) simply by declaring their insolvency would be drastically limited, according to… Mai mult

Phil Hogan: Swine fever in Romania has an impact on neighbouring countries and EU trade in pigs

Prime Minister Viorica Dancila, European Commissioner Phil Hogan and Agriculture Minister Petre Daea The swine fever epidemics in Romania has an impact on neighbouring countries,… Mai mult

Infrastructure projects lost EUR 41.5 million following budget amendment. In what projects cuts have been made

Despite the assurances that Dancila government is concerned and intensely working on the road infrastructure projects, at the budget amendment the Transport Ministry has cut… Mai mult

European Parliament have decided to adopt in October a resolution on the rule of law in Romania

Leaders of the political groups in the European Parliament have decided to adopt in October a resolution on the rule of law in Romania. The… Mai mult

"Romania's buffers have deteriorated, the country is less prepared for a negative shock" - IMF will reduce economic growth estimate

Romania will be less prepared if the economy is hit by a negative shock, as the structural deficit has been deteriorated - IMF representative for… Mai mult

Premiere: CSAT asks Finance Ministry to amend amendment - session suspended until Government comes with a draft that does not affect budgets of secret services

President Klaus Iohannis suspended on Tuesday the CSAT meeting for discussing the budget amendment, as there was no consensus on the budgets of institutions from… Mai mult

S&P maintains Romania's rating at "BBB-A-3", with a stable outlook: arguments

Rating agency Standard & Poor's confirmed on Friday ratings for long- and short-term debt in foreign and local currency to "BBB-/A-3" with a stable outlook,… Mai mult

"Romania’s presidency seems to fail before it starts": Gunther Krichbaum - reaction to anti-German violent statements made by government officials

Romania's presidency of the Council of the European Union seems to fail even before it starts, warns Chairman of the Bundestag European Affairs Committee Gunther… Mai mult

OMV Petrom sells a quarter of its deposit perimeters to finance potential gas extraction from Black Sea

OMV Petrom (SNP) will sell another 50-60 perimeters from its portfolio of about 200, as most of the company's investments focus on operating the Black… Mai mult

Emigration continues: 220,000 Romanians left the country in 2017

The number of people who left the country for more than 12 months continued to grow last year, reaching almost 220,000 people (which exceeds the… Mai mult

181 magistrates sign a criticizing letter addressed to Minister of Justice

The Minister of Justice stirred up the fury of magistrates. 181 prosecutors and judges sent him a letter criticizing Tudorel Toader for his statements about… Mai mult

Canada takes over air-policing missions operated from Mihail Kogalniceanu base

MApN announced on Wednesday that Mihail Kogalniceanu Air Base 57 had a ceremony occasioned by the handing over of the Enhanced Air Policing between the… Mai mult

Ministry of Finance is drafting a new fiscal framework valid as of January 1, 2019

The Ministry of Public Finance makes a "comparative analysis" of the Tax Code and the Tax Procedure Code with a view to applying a new… Mai mult

Eurostat: Romania and evolution of employee number in public sector in an European context

Romania, Hungary and Slovenia are the member states that recorded the largest increase in the share of public sector employees in the total number of… Mai mult