So it begins / Ombudsman challenges in the CCR law banning offenders to lead Romania. “Indignation” for the Presidency: it opens the door for convicts to take decisions

de Mariana Bechir | 8.1.2017 .

victor-ciorbeaSo it begins / Ombudsman challenges in the CCR law banning offenders to lead Romania. “Indignation” for the Presidency: it opens the door for convicts to take decisions

The Ombudsman filed a notice to the CCR, Thursday, on the unconstitutionality of art. 2 of Law 90/2001 that does not allow criminal convicts to hold a minister positions – consequently, it does not allow Liviu Dragnea to be prime minister, neither minister, because of the definitive because of the definitive suspended conviction.

The main reason of the notice: the law would violate the principle of checks and balances of powers in a state.

What the respective article of the law says:

Accession to the Government as a member is open to the persons who have only Romanian citizenship and residence in the country, enjoy the exercise of electoral rights, have no criminal convictions and are not in any of the incompatibility situations stipulated in art. 4 paragraph (1).

Arguments of the notice

  • Lack of legislative consistency, even within the same power of the state – Law for the election of the President (part of the executive power) does not provide for the impossibility to elect a convicted person to this position and for the MPs (legislative power), the mandate is not conditional on this matter unless the court has decided a complementary penalty involving the electoral rights. Firm interdiction exists in the case of magistrates (judicial power)
  • Lack of predictability of the wording ” have no criminal convictions”. It can allow various interpretations
  • Lack of a differential legal treatment – between convicts who committed offenses intentionally and those convicted of negligence, which leads to violating certain civil and political rights. For instance, article 21 section 2 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights stating that “any person has the right to access, on an equal basis, to the public functions in her country.”
  • Legislation must meet the constitutional principle of checks and balances of powers, and this balance cannot be achieved unless there is a consistent system designed to ensure generally applicable integrity requirements in exercising the functions from these three powers

Presidency’s reaction: It can open the gate to sentenced criminals to lead

Romanian President is outraged by the action of the Ombudsman from this morning, an action having a single beneficiary. Romanian President is surprised by how quickly the Ombudsman is willing to be useful to the new majority,” said Thursday the President’s spokesperson, Madalina Dobrovolschi.

She explained that the efforts of a sentenced person willing to become prime minister are not part of the Ombudsman’s duty.

By this notice in the Constitutional Court, the Ombudsman “can open the gate to sentenced criminals to lead,” she also added.

“Nobody, ever, considered that this criterion of morality is a problem for the political life in Romania” and for 16 years “the Ombudsman has not considered that the text of the law is a matter for civil rights and freedoms”, said the spokesperson of the Romanian Presidency.

Dobrovolschi cited article 58 paragraph 1 of the Constitution which clearly states that the role of the Ombudsman is to “defend the rights and freedoms of natural persons,” and explained that “the efforts of a convicted person to become prime minister falls outside the agenda” belonging to Victor Ciorbea.

Ombudsman Victor Ciorbea: 5 notices in 2016

This is the first notice of unconstitutionality filed to the CCR this year by the Ombudsman and, if accepted, would allow Liviu Dragnea to become prime minister.

Dragnea’s intention to take over this position has been expressed within a statement at the nomination of Sevil Shhaideh:

“According to the usages from us and other civilized countries, I had the right to ask the mandate for me, as PSD won the election. At the same time, I took into account two things: President’s statements and a law currently in force. I do not wish to ask for this function, for now.

During the past year, the institution challenged in the Constitutional Court only five provisions:

March – the Ombudsman notified the Constitutional Court on the exception of unconstitutionality related to the Emergency Ordinance 17/2010 for completing Title XI “Agricultural life annuity” of Law no. 247/2005 on the reform of property and justice, on the grounds that an article has been added contrary to the principle of non-retroactivity of the law. The Ombudsman considered that the person is required, on 5 March 2010, to have a certain conduct, even before the emergency ordinance comes into force, which was not provided for by the existing norm at the time, namely to have filed for obtaining the agricultural life annuity by 31 December 2009, inclusive.

May – the Ombudsman filed a notice to the CCR on the emergency ordinance allowing for a referendum to be organised simultaneously with local elections. The notice followed a request from PSD that was willing to block the referendum on the unification of Sinmartin village with Oradea city.

July – Exception of constitutionality relating to the protection zones existing on both sides of the road safety areas. According to the Government Ordinance 43/1997, republished, they remain under the management of the legal persons or individuals who administer or own them. These owners pay tax at the rate of 100% on the land, although they would hardly be able to use it, and even more, they have certain restrictions in this regard, with high obligations imposed on them, as the owners of the land, which may become onerous. This would harm the lawful private interests of the owners.

November – the Ombudsman filed a noticed to the Constitutional Court on some legal provisions regarding the patient’s electronic health record that do not guarantee enough protection of the right to intimate, family and private life. The Ombudsman considered that the access and use of data from the electronic health record of the patient must be done under maximum security conditions, to preclude dissemination (even accidental) of any personal data that could prejudice a person in any way.

December – the objection of unconstitutionality on a provision of the Tax Code requiring a person who no longer owns a good to pay tax on construction, land or means of transport. This respective provision forces the person who was the owner of that good at 31 December, in the preceding fiscal year, to pay this tax, which the Ombudsman considered to be inadequate and disproportionate to the aim set, as it affects the personal property of the taxpayers.

Important unconstitutional laws that Victor Ciorbea refused to challenge

In 2014, Ciorbea stubbornly refused to challenge the famous Ordinance 55, called the ordinance of migration, which temporarily suspended the sanction on the local elected officials joining a different party than the one with which they had submitted their candidacies and got elected to their position. PSD wanted to recover this way the mayors lost following the dissolution of USL.

The opposition parties, President Traian Basescu and NGOs asked him to challenge the ordinance in the CCR and the US Embassy also showed concern about the timing of issuing such a law (it was before the presidential elections).

NGOs and the opposition even picketed against the institution, but Victor Ciorbea answered to the protests by claiming that the action “particularly refers to the relationship between the public authorities, aspects of the functioning of the constitutional democracy involving an especially political analysis and approach”, which would ask for the institution “to go beyond its position of neutrality and objectivity and involve in partisan controversies.

The emergency ordinance has been declared unconstitutional, but following a notice from PNL. In the short period of its applicability, hundreds of liberal and PDL mayors have transferred to PSD.

Also in 2014, Victor Ciorbea denied the appeal from the civil society, a part of media and the President, to challenge the changes made by the former Minister Sorin Campeanu on the Education Law.

Among the provisions of this ordinance, there were several references to PhDs. For instance, the emergency ordinance included an article providing for the possibility of giving up the title, which would have allowed plagiarists to go without the penalty for the intellectual fraud they committed.

Right after the publication of the ordinance, Victor Ponta sent a statement to the Ministry of Education announcing that he gives up his title. The request remained unanswered as the rules for the application of the ordinance have not been drafted anymore.

A PNL member, Victor Ciorbea was nominated by PSD for the Ombudsman position

Victor Ciorbea was voted for the Ombudsman position in 2014, following the nomination made by PSD, although he was a PNL member at the time.

The liberals did not agree with the nomination and left the plenary hall when the vote took place.

A former union leader in the early 90s, Ciorbea joined politics at the time of the Democratic Convention’s establishment.

He was the mayor of the capital city and prime minister (between 12 December 1996 and 30 March 1998).

In 2011, he was elected chairman of PNTCD, but transferred to PNL following the internal scandals from this party and obtained a parliamentary term in the Senate on the PNL lists, in 2012.

Publicat la data de 8.1.2017 .

Lasa un comentariu


SIMILAR ARTICLES

Marin Pana

European Semester: a summary about Romania in 2017. Brussels data do not “match” at all those from Bucharest

  The European Commission (EC) shows in the 2017 country report on Romania that, by reversing the consolidation trend, the fiscal policy turned pro-cyclical in 2016 and the deficit is widening Driven by significant tax cuts and expenditure hikes, the general government deficit will increase further to 36% in 2017 and 39% in 2018 Contrary to the forecast that the Government presented, ...
Read more »

Adrian N Ionescu

Real economy: Profits of large companies in 2016 hide consumption increase tensions. Dividend ranking

The tensions hidden by Romania's economic growth in 2016 (48%) are visible in the results of the 20 largest Romanian companies listed on the Bucharest Stock Exchange (BSE), according to their data reported to the stock exchange The 2016 results of the companies from the BSE Top 20 "suggest that the economic growth was based mainly on consumption and investment with no speed," said Mihai ...
Read more »

Cristian Grosu

Cristian Grosu / Do not be stupid: Trap for a perverse political class to keep the domestic and foreign capital. Some examples

  I usually do not keep in touch with the mob representatives that decapitalized Romania, even if some of them were sources of information for me in the last 24 years Taking that into account, I have a strong admiration and determination to help in any way and anytime I can Romanian entrepreneurs who have managed to remain standing despite the hostile environment in which they evolved ...
Read more »

Marin Pana

Wonderful world of salaries and pensions in the next 4 years: “we have a problem!”

The Minister of Labour Lia Olguta Vasilescu confirmed last week in a TV show that the pension and salary increases will apply in the next four years exactly as they are written in the electoral leaflet of the main governing party If applied as they have been presented, a major issue for the Romanian economy is worryingly taking shape: the sustainability of the pension system To simplify the ...
Read more »

Victor Bratu

Why Romania fails to join OECD: criteria that it does not meet and what to do

Romania's accession to the OECD is a major goal of the Romanian foreign policy since 2004 After 7 governments at Victoria Palace and 13 years since establishing this objective, during which the OECD has received new members 2 times (2004 and 2012), Romania is still waiting for a favourable decision According to an OECD report issued in December 2016, the wait seems to be lasting and does ...
Read more »


NEWS

2017 started with a decreasing confidence in economy and leu, according to CFA Romania Index

The index of macroeconomic confidence has declined for the second consecutive month, down to 54.9 points in January 201, of 100 points in total. “The ... Read more

One of 102 taxes eliminated is back: Daniel Constantin announces new version of car pollution tax

Daniel Constantin probably has not read the program of the PSD government The Minister of Environment Daniel Constantin (foto) announced on Tuesday that, probably next ... Read more

Competition Council investigates why fuel prices in Romania exceeds the EU average

The Competition Council has launched a sectoral investigation on the fuel market, to analyse why the prices in Romania are above the EU average, said ... Read more

2017 European Semester, analysis on Romania: growth above potential, worrying deficit estimates

Despite Romania’s progress in implementing the recommendations of the European Commission (EC), “the structural challenges may dampen the medium-term outlook,” mentions the report on Romania. ... Read more

2017 trends : Bucharest Stock Exchange indices hit new 5-year highs. BET exceeded psychological threshold of 8,000 points

The most important indices of the Bucharest Stock Exchange (BSE) registered new 5-year high Wednesday at noon and continued the favourable trend of the last ... Read more

World Bank, interested to support founding of Sovereign Investment Fund

Alexandru Petrescu, Minister of Economy The World Bank is interested in the announcement that Romania plans to establish a Sovereign Fund for Development and Investment ... Read more

Memorandum: Sovereign Fund to be financed from selling shares of state companies and bonds

To obtain financing, the Sovereign Fund for Development and Investment (FSDI) planned by the Government will sell shares in the state companies received in its ... Read more

Law on hypermarkets / European Commission launched infringement procedures against Romania and Hungary

The European Commission started on Wednesday the infringement procedure against Romania and Hungary on the matter of retail of agricultural and food products. More specifically, it ... Read more

Romania, referred to CJEU over illegal landfills. EC asks Bucharest to allow Bulgarians to have equal access to fish from Black Sea

The European Commission has decided to bring Romania in The Court of Justice of the European Union because the country has not closed and rehabilitated ... Read more

Forest Stewardship Council permanently withdrew certification for wood processed by Schweighofer

The international organization Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) announced Friday in a press release that permanently withdraws the certification for the wood processed by Austrian group ... Read more

Historical demographic records in 2016: Lowest number of live births after 1876 and largest negative natural growth in history

The natural growth was negative in December 2016, as the number of deaths surpassed the live births by 9,782 people. The data for the entire ... Read more

BNR forecasts lower economic growth than Government. Explanation: different "macroeconomic model"

The National Bank of Romania (BNR) forecasts the economic growth between 4% and 5% in 2017, based on its macroeconomic model; its estimation would have ... Read more

Government amends, only 3 months after last change, the method of approving price of medicines. Industry claims 48% of the market is disrupted

The Ministry of Health has launched to public debate a government decision draft to amend the calculation methodology and the endorsement/approval procedure for the maximal ... Read more

EIU: Economic growth may slow down to 3.6% in 2017, while budget deficit could reach 3.3% of GDP. Other estimates

Romania might register in 2017 an economic growth slowdown to 3.6% from the 2016 estimate of 5%, and a budget deficit of 3.3% based on the ... Read more

Klaus Iohannis in Parliament: Legislate for Romania not for some politicians with problems. Do what you promised during elections, do not make fun

President Klaus Iohannis assured on Tuesday that he does not intend to change in any way the result of the parliamentary elections, asking instead for ... Read more

Four largest universities and Ad Astra Association: Government reorganizes, namely re-politicises research domain

  The Minister of Research prepares the “reorganization of the advisory bodies” under the authority of the ministry, which risks to undo “any effort made ... Read more

A new phenomenon: brands’ revolt. How advertising decreased on Romania TV and Antena 3 news channels because of tendentious reporting on protests against Government

Against the background of protests caused by the Government’s initiative to amend the Criminal Code by emergency ordinance and the call of Frontline Club for ... Read more

Government becomes more powerful than Parliament. When reality is entitled to contradict Constitutional Court

  Romania’s Constitutional Court ruled Wednesday, 8 February, following the examination of the request received from President Klaus Iohannis, that there is no constitutional conflict ... Read more

Head of Joint Standing Committee for Exercise of Parliamentary Control over Romanian Intelligent Service asks for investigations on multinationals who allegedly urged employees to attend protests. IPP calls for his resignation

Senator Adrian Tutuianu (PSD), Chairman of the Joint Standing Committee for the Exercise of Parliamentary Control over the Activity of the Romanian Intelligent Service (SRI), ... Read more

Upgrade in financing for Romania: Without listing Hidroelectrica, promoting Romanian capital market to emerging market status faces further waiting time

The Romanian capital market needs to meet only one more criterion, out of nine, in order to be promoted from frontier market to emerging market ... Read more

Minister of Economy: Royalties should have a correct level from regional perspective, for different types of resources

The Ministry of Economy and Energy is currently working on a new system of royalties, to allow investors’ access to a clear list of all ... Read more