SIMILAR ARTICLES

BNR – Risk map: Credit default risk got right to “high” level top position

The deterioration of investors’ confidence in emerging economies and the default risk of loans to companies and population are the biggest risks to financial stability… Mai mult

A (new) paradox: Public debt decreases as a share of GDP – cost increases with interest to what we borrow. Remarks

Although medium- and long-term foreign debt (DETML) has declined steadily over the last four years related to GDP, the amount paid for this debt has… Mai mult

Current account deficit – 15% higher after first four months of 2018

The current account of the balance of payments registered a deficit of EUR 2,053 million in the first four months of this year, about 15%… Mai mult

We and Juncker Plan: Bulgaria – 3rd position, Romania – 23rd position. How other neighbours are doing

The value and economic impact of the Romanian projects to attract resources from the so-called “Juncker Plan” of European investments are much lower, compared to… Mai mult

Sovereign Fund has been voted: Mechanism to remove “states’ pearls” from public control

The voting machine of the Chamber of Deputies (decision chamber) approved on Wednesday – 174 votes for, 98 against and 3 abstentions – the Law… Mai mult

Public pension systems in EU – Bismarck versus Beveridge. Romania: “Sure ain’t no one like us”

de Marin Pana , 23.5.2018

European countries have quite diverse pension systems in terms of financing methods but basically based on two models, Bismarck and Beveridge. The former is mostly based on contributions targeted to social protection, the second one on general fees collected.

The result is that the Bismarck model tends to limit the redistribution of benefits between different categories of citizens’ incomes, while the Beveridge model inherently contains a redistribution of money collected.

Technically, the first aims at preserving the living standard of those who contribute based on certain contribution criteria, while the latter aims at ensuring the subsistence by a uniform standard.

Although necessary for understanding the different situations in the practice of different states, these considerations are theoretical.

In fact, no country has a pure Bismarck or pure Beveridge system, and there have been changes over time from one model to the other.

*

  • Structure of financing for social protection expenses
  • Contributions (% of total)
  • General           government     social   employer         employee        other

*

The most recent data available from Eurostat shows that the main source of financing of social expenses (where pensions have the “lion’s share”) were social contributions. They accounted for 54.1% of the total, compared to 40.5% of the general taxes collected by the government.

It is noteworthy that there is also a 5.5% part from “other sources” (which, pay attention, in our case, include the property taxes). In this chapter, not only the UK or the Netherlands have excelled, but also the country having the structure of the economy and the level of development closest to ours, Poland, all these above the 10% threshold compared to only 1.4% in our case.

Some northern countries, where government funding is predominant, are anchored in the tradition of the Beveridge system (where it is enough to be resident to be eligible for social benefits). Denmark (79.8%) and Ireland (60.5%) have the largest shares of government funding and, implicitly, lower social contributions (only 11% of the total in Denmark!). Also, Malta, Sweden and Cyprus have a funding share of over 50% representing sources of general contributions.

Other countries had rather chosen the Bismarck system, based on the concept of social insurance, where funding from contributions with this special purpose is predominant. Interestingly, Estonia is the champion of this type of approach (81.7% of the amounts come from social contributions) and other former socialist countries, Lithuania and the Czech Republic, surpass the country where this system originates, Germany (with 70.9% and 70%, respectively, versus 65%).

It is worth considering the Netherland’s approach, which has a share of social contributions similar to Germany, but it significantly supports the system by taxing the property and not just by general taxes, like Germany which does that almost exclusively (which has a share representing the “other sources” category similar to Romania and Bulgaria).

It is also worth mentioning Italy’s structure, which we overlap almost precisely. This shows that, beyond the strictly economic aspects, the decision in this matter essentially depends on the socio-cultural model deeply impregnated in the common origin.

On the other hand, if we compare to the group of countries from Central Europe, the data show quite clearly that Romania has a discordant note in terms of financing the social protection and it might be useful for us to take steps towards the convergence with these countries.

Finally, if we look at the employer’s share compared to the employee’s one (where Eurostat data have not yet integrated the transfer of social contributions almost exclusively to the Romanian employee, which obviously no longer happens in any EU member state) we see that (along with Bulgarians and Italians), we have applied neither the Bismarck nor the Beveridge system in a clear way, but an original employer/employee distribution, based on the principle “sure ain’t no one like us”. It is our sovereign right, but is that okay?

Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 23.5.2018

Lăsați un comentariu


NEWS

Subsidy of RON 900/month for employing a graduate based on contracts of indefinite duration

The National Agency for Employment (ANOFM) grants subsidies of RON 900/month to employers who employ graduates of educational institutions, with contracts of indefinite duration, within… Mai mult

C.P. Tariceanu, before the heads of Senates from EU: The European Commission has encouraged the parallel state, in Romania it is like in the 50's

Calin Popescu Tariceanu (foto) delivered a very tough speech on Friday, in the Senate, addressed to the European Commission, which he accused of encouraging the… Mai mult

National Bank of Romania wants to lower indebtedness limit in granting loans to individuals

The National Bank of Romania (BNR) sent to banks for consultation a draft amending Regulation 17/2012, which provides for a consistent lowering of the indebtedness… Mai mult

High impact provisions: Senate has adopted PSD-ALDE amendments to the Code of Criminal Procedure

Senators adopted on Wednesday the draft for amending the Code of Criminal Procedure, by 74 votes for to 28, against. The bill goes to the… Mai mult

RBL: Workforce crisis is worse than economic crisis - 3.4 million Romanians have left the country in last 10 years

Migration is one of the most serious problems facing Romania at this time, along with the lack of infrastructure. However, the return of Romanians to… Mai mult

World Bank: Romania's economy could grow by 5.1% in 2018

Romania's economy could grow by 5.1% in 2018, according to the World Bank summer forecast. The estimate has been improved by 0.6 percentage points above… Mai mult

Ministry of Energy: Natural gas from Black Sea will be exported through Onesti - Isaccea - Negru Voda network

The Ministry of Energy issued for Transgaz the construction permit for the consolidation of the transport system between Onesti (Bacau) and Isaccea (Tulcea) and for… Mai mult

Energy productivity: Romania goes up within Central European group

Romania reached 56% of the EU's average energy productivity in 2016, compared to only 43% in the year of the accession, according to data released… Mai mult

Document / Public procurement - Changes made by OUG: how to calculate guarantees, values over which contract must be publicly announced, how to change contract without resuming procedures

Under the promise of reducing bureaucracy and increasing efficiency in the public procurement procedure, the Government approved on Thursday an emergency ordinance that brings essential… Mai mult

AmCham: Romania should have a national investment plan. Four major areas with competitive potential

The consistency of the measures needed to encourage public and private investment, as well as proposals for the development of the four major areas considered… Mai mult

"We are pulling ourselves out of maps!": Business community’s solutions for infrastructure development

In the medium and long term, companies in Romania lose business because of disarticulated infrastructure; the country overall loses new investment, the state budget loses… Mai mult

New Romania’s Agent at the EU Court of Justice: 32 years old, failed exams, a person supported by Olguta Vasilescu

The government agent at the EU Court of Justice, Razvan Horatiu Radu, was replaced by the Government by a decision of Prime Minister Viorica Dancila… Mai mult

European Commission urges Government to "fully and immediately" reimburse car taxes

The European Commission asks Romania to urgently align the system of taxes collected on the car registration to the European one. The request is announced… Mai mult

CCR President in a visit to Russia, despite that Ministry of Foreign Affairs has recommended not to make this visit

CCR President Valer Dorneanu is in Russia today, where he attends the Sankt Petersburg International Legal Forum, despite that MAE has recommended not to make… Mai mult

List of black payments / Corruption in health sectors: Bribes - 25% of contract value, higher than in other fields

Romania is the European country with the lowest spending in the health sector. However, DNA statistics show that the bribe in this field is higher… Mai mult