2018 EU Cohesion Monitor: What should Romania understand between the lines

The Berlin Think Tank European Council of Foreign Relations (ECFR) published the 2018 edition of the EU Cohesion Monitor – an analysis of the cohesion… Mai mult

Winter forecast: CNP radically adjusts economic growth. Observations on game of deficit, exchange rate, inflationv

The National Prognosis Commission (CNP), an institution under the government authority, radically changed the economic growth for 2017, from 6.1% in last autumn forecast to… Mai mult

Average income trap – danger for Romania and CEE states: Setting growth engine on innovation is the only solution          

In the absence of strategies to increase technological levels and raise wages, Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) will remain in the average income trap without… Mai mult

Romania – biggest reduction in energy consumption in EU. Causes, consequences, opportunities

According to the data published by Eurostat, Romania recorded the biggest decline in the gross energy consumption between 1996 and 2016 and the cumulated value… Mai mult

How we stand with the money and on what we spend. A plus of 40% to personal income in four years, a 20% increase in GDP over the same period

The data published by the INS for the third quarter of 2017 show that the total average income of a household reached 3,426 lei per… Mai mult

Major surprise: CNP increases 2017 growth forecast by 0.5%. A sublime explanation

de Marin Pana , 6.11.2017

In the autumn forecast on which the 2018 budget is based, the National Commission for Prognosis, an institution under the Government’s authority, increased the economic growth projection for the current year to 6.1%, from the level of 5.6% announced only a few weeks ago in the preliminary autumn forecast.

The value used as a benchmark for the 2017 GDP (including for the general budget deficit, which threatens to exceed 3%), went up again. Started from RON 815.2 billion at the beginning of the year, it reached along the way (somewhere after the summer vacation) RON 837.1 billion and now it is mentioned the level of RON 842.5 billion.


  • Year
  • Version Q1
  • Version Q2


Not only the GDP result for the current year has been re-evaluated upwards by 0.65% but also all values until 2021. To be mentioned, all the values projected for the euro/ leu average annual exchange rate have been maintained, decreasing from 4.56 lei/euro for the current year to 4.50 lei in 2021 (?).

A warning signal for those who closely follow the data of the national economy, the annual GDP values for the interval until 2021, expressed in billions of euros, have been removed from the usual form of the table presented by CNP. From the values related to GDP/inhabitant, only those in RON remained while those expressed in EUR/inhabitant have disappeared.

Explanation is sublime

The CNP’s explanation for the spectacular and so far, one-time increase of the GDP growth estimate by half a percentage point in just a few weeks could only be found at the level of a radical change in the gross value added in the economy. Let’s see what the re-evaluation of the development pace in the main economic sectors indicates:


  • Increase of 2017 gross value added in the economy            Q1       Q2       change
  • Industry
  • Agriculture
  • Construction
  • Services


As the growth rate of the other component of GDP, net taxes on the product stagnated at + 4.2%, it results that the increase in the economic growth estimate appeared after the industry (the main engine of the Romanian economy) and agriculture have been re-evaluated significantly downward and services have changed their growth up by only a tenth of a percent.

The only plausible explanation (which should also cover the declines in the industry and agriculture!) comes from the construction sector, where the change from 1.5% to 7% within a few weeks appears to be quite bizarre. The correct recording of the production obtained and, particularly, of the intermediary consumption based on which it has been obtained, should be carefully monitored.

Change trick – 6.4% growth in second semester of 2017!

Without the need for in-depth knowledge of mathematics, let us simplify the situation at this point in relation to GDP developments in the second half of the year. For the first part of the year, we already have the seasonally adjusted value published by INS at the level of + 5.8%.

From the preliminary version, we knew that there would be a slight growth slowdown to only + 5.4% in the second half of the year, from which a perfectly plausible and otherwise very good 5.6% level for the entire 2017 would have resulted.

Now we have found ourselves with an AVERAGE OF 6.1% FOR THE WHOLE 2017. What does that mean? Well, like in the elementary school, it means that we need not just + 5.4% in the second half of the year to obtain the average level, but + 6.4%! That is, not some slowdown in growth but rather a strong acceleration, with a new record at the European level in the field.

For this purpose, the GDP deflator, which measures the prices in the economy and by which nominal GDP values decrease then to make the transition to the base period prices, more accurately THE REAL ECONOMIC GROWTH, has been discreetly increased from 4.1% to 4.2%. And that even though inflation measured by the consumer price index has been re-evaluated upwards from 1.9% to 2.2% (and from 2.3% to 2.6% in 2018, when the deflator still appears at 2.1 !?).

Obviously, the situation created by these disruptions of indicators from which the forecasted GDP growth results resembles the jokes with Radio Erevan. That would be a good occasion for jokes about statistics if CNP data were not the basis for 2018 budgeting process. A year when we might not find ourselves in the mood for jokes anymore.

Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 6.11.2017

Lăsați un comentariu


AOAR: Solutions to imbalances produced by chaotic tax legislation - business environment reaction to a slander from a minister

The Businessmen's Association of Romania (AOAR) proposes a series of solutions to get out of the "chaos" of the fiscal and revenue legislation adopted last… Mai mult

Government has approved OUG to preserve income of IT and part-time employees

The Government approved on Thursday the OUG comprising the measures needed to preserve net wages that professional groups exempted from income tax and part-time employees… Mai mult

EBRD: Romania needs to change its economic growth model. Better "sooner than later"

Romania needs to adopt a different economic model if it wants to avoid a crisis caused by the current consumption boom, according to Matteo Patrone,… Mai mult

INS - Context survey: stability or even stagnation, employees about the same but all prices up!

According to the perception of managers from the field, the manufacturing industry will register a relative stability of production volume in the following months (conjuncture… Mai mult

Romanian Business Leaders: List of "signs of distrust" in economic year 2018

The Romanian Business Leaders (RBL) Macroeconomic Confidence Index, of 52.3 points, shows that the entrepreneurs and executives from the most important businesses in Romania have… Mai mult

OLAF runs investigation at Metrorex - possible overpriced payments at Metro Line 5

UPDATE: In a statement issued to RFI, OLAF confirmed the investigation at Metrorex, and its topic - the Metro Line 5 (M5) financed by European… Mai mult

Government goes on Eurobond market and attracts over EUR 3 billion. Complicated yields

The Ministry of Finance is trying to take advantage of the still favourable conditions for emerging government securities and goes on the Eurobonds market with… Mai mult

MFP: Government will borrow RON 74 billion in 2018, only through government bonds

The total volume of loans planned by the Ministry of Finance (MFP) for 2018 amounts to about RON 74 billion. Loans are to be secured… Mai mult

Pessimistic expectations about the future in latest CFA Romania research - economists anticipate a decrease of personal incomes and continuous depreciation of Romanian leu

In December 2017, the macroeconomic confidence indicator of CFA Romania declined to 41 points, the lowest value since April 2013, by 3.1 points below the… Mai mult

Second largest bank in EU, BNP Paribas, opens its branch in Bucharest

BNP Paribas, the largest French bank and the second largest in the EU by the size of assets, will launch its retail operations in Romania… Mai mult

Three options by which BNR intends to moderate lending

The BNR will impose restrictions on credits to the population, to anticipate potential non-payment risks. This could happen in March if the project is approved… Mai mult

Siegfried Muresan: Amendments to Romanian laws on judicial will be discussed in European Parliament

The European Parliament will run debates on the situation of justice in Romania in the next plenary session, in February, in the Strasbourg plenary. The… Mai mult

State has initiated procedure for purchasing 51% of Daewoo's shares at Mangalia Shipyard

The Government approved in the last meeting a memorandum stating that the state will use its preemption right at Mangalia Shipyard and buy the 51%… Mai mult

First major acquisition in 2018 - MApN signs contract with General Dynamics to acquire 227 armoured carriers

Minister of National Defence, Mihai Fifor, participates Friday at the signing of the procurement contract for 227 Piranha V armoured carriers, a release of the… Mai mult

Business environment: Waiving governance rules in state-owned companies, another measure that deepens feeling of distrust

The Foreign Investors Council (FIC) released on Wednesday a statement that expresses its dissatisfaction with the "authorities’ political agenda" containing decisions that "will lead to… Mai mult