SIMILAR ARTICLES

National gross minimum wage: in Romania and EU countries

  Romania ranks second to last among EU states in terms of national gross minimum wage, according to data published by Eurostat, at a level… Mai mult

Some charts: Perfect chaos in Romanian budgets. A 4-year analysis of difference between law and implementation

Although at first glance it is difficult to draft them, Romania’s public budgets are, in fact, a series of indicators and lists of revenues and… Mai mult

Tax authority’s “armed arm” was handed over to Prognosis Commission. How strongest governmental structure looks?

ANAF’s new president, Mihaela Triculescu, handed over to the National Commission for Strategy and Prognosis – CNSP the power to decide what companies are to… Mai mult

Current account deficit – Romania goes to opposite direction compared to EU countries

Romania is clearly distinguishing itself within the EU in terms of current account deficit evolution, with the second highest current account deficit in 2017 and… Mai mult

Legislative Council had already pulled “Ordinance on greed” to pieces even before its adoption: You create bases of a centralized economy and exempt yourself from fiscal-budgetary responsibility

  The opinion issued in December by the Legislative Council on Ordinance 114 (which establishes, among other things, the “tax on greed”) contains no less… Mai mult

Cronicile
Banca Transilvania campanie aniversara 25 ani

Graph: Health of Romanian economic growth compared to Polish growth. Explanations and consequences

de Adrian N Ionescu , 1.10.2018

The growth of the Romanian economy over the last decade has been impressive in nominal value, above all other EU states.

But it has a big congenital problem: over the last 10 years, Romania has gained less than Poland did from lower but much more stable growth rates.

The average annual growth rate in the last 10 years was 2.5% in Romania and 3.3% in Poland, according to Eurostat data, in current prices and national currencies.

The economic growth evolution illustrates the wide range of variations in Romania’s case, with distant extremes, while Polish increases had lower extremes but only positive values.

*

  • Evolution of economic growth in Romania and Poland

*

Increase “from wages” versus sustainable growth

Romania’s GDP grew by 8.3% in 2008 based on the unsustainable consumption growth resulted from wage increases.

The result was that, while Romania had afterward two years of recession, deep in 2009 (-5.9%) and severe in 2010 (-2.8%), Poland only altered its growth rate in 2009 (to 2.8%, from 4.2% in 2008).

Also in 2017, the 6.9% increase was almost exclusively the result of earlier wage increases, as well as a fiscal loosening that encouraged consumption.

The negative correction of the rhythm in 2018 will again be deep in Romania (down to almost half compared to 2017 – analysts say).

*

  • Erste Group Research macroeconomic estimations

*

At the same time, Poland will increase its growth rate (from 4.6% to 4.9, according to Erste Group Research).

Quality of growth

Differences in the quality of growth are added to statistical differences and Romania’s growth seriously affect the chances of progress in the future.

In 2009, Poland’s strengths were the stable and developed domestic market and the ability of decision-makers to control imbalances, according to the IMF.

Instead, Romania’s economy collapsed, unbalanced by the effects of massive imports that fuelled consumption.

Then Romania had to cut wages and increase VAT, while Poland knew how to use European funds to maintain growth during the crisis within the positive range and could cut income tax and stimulate consumption at the right time.

In 2017 the two economies were stimulated by consumption, but again with proportions that have damaged the balances in Romania, respectively preserved balances in Poland.

The budget deficit was 1.7% of GDP in Poland last year, while the Romanian Government barely managed to maintain it at 2.9% (one step below the EU’s maximum accepted level).

Last year Poland recorded a surplus in the current account (even though of only 0.2%), while the Romanian current account deficit was 3.3% of GDP.

Signs of current dangers

The indicators of Polish and Romanian economies differ now as dangerously as before for the Romanian economy, (within the statistical proportions).

The evolution of the construction sector is negative in Romania and positive in Poland.

The Polish economy confirmed its growth rate in Q2 of 2018 (5.2% y-o-y after 5.1% in Q1).

In Poland, “the sharp decline in investment was almost entirely offset by the acceleration of exports,” says a Capital Economics report issued on Tuesday.

Instead, the Romanian economy continued to slow down its growth rate (4.2%) after a previous rhythm collapse.

In Romania, not only are investments decreasing, but net exports are negative.

In Poland, wage increase will also trigger the increase in inflation, but it tends towards capping (2.0% in August, after 1.9% in July).

In Romania, salary increases of 14.4% (y-o-y in May) led to a significant increase in inflation to 5.1% in August, compared to 4.6% in July.

Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 1.10.2018

Lăsați un comentariu


NEWS

Commissioner Corina Cretu: There is a risk that Magurele Laser will not be completed during this budget implementation

In the absence of a rapid response from the Romanian Government to the European Commission, there is a risk that Magurele Laser can no longer… Mai mult

Romania joins countries that recognize Juan Guaidó as interim president of Venezuela

The Presidential Administration announced on Friday that President Klaus Iohannis, "as the head of Romania’s foreign policy decisions and Romania's representative at the external level,… Mai mult

AmCham Romania: Counterproductive public policies have reched an alarming level

Further to the message on the impact of OUG 114/2018 transmitted on Thursday to the organizations in the Coalition for Development of Romania (CDR), AmCham… Mai mult

Finance minister stopped borrowing money from the market. Teodorovici: We have funding resources for minimum six months

Minister of Public Finance (MFP), Eugen Orlando Teodorovici, has ordered to stop borrowing operations on the market because MFF would have all the money needed… Mai mult

BNR: If we sold foreign currency to defend Romanian leu, as PSD wants, interest rates would explode and ROBOR would go over 5-7 percentage points

The National Bank of Romania wants a "loyal cooperation" with the Ministry of Public Finance, and that involves a prior consultation with the central bank… Mai mult

Tax on bank assets was not included in 2019 draft budget

The tax on bank assets was not included in the 2019 draft budget, published on Thursday evening by the Ministry of Public Finance (MFP). According… Mai mult

Eruption on foreign exchange market: Mechanism of spiralling depreciation. Euro - sudden surge to 4,759

The average euro exchange rate, calculated by the National Bank of Romania (BNR), suddenly climbed sharply to a new record level of 4.7569 RON /… Mai mult

ANAF starts controls at large taxpayers. Mission stated: Combating phenomenon of externalisation of profits

The National Agency for Fiscal Administration has publicly announced the start of the "Iceberg" operation - a large fiscal control action targeting big companies operating… Mai mult

It becomes increasingly harder for the state to borrow: Finance Ministry has attracted only a quarter of targeted 400 million

The Ministry of Finance (MFP) has only managed to sell five-year government bonds amounted to RON 110 million out of the RON 400 million issued… Mai mult

"Perfect storm" that "calls for a crisis": Bankers - about "greed ordinance"

The most important bankers in Romania say that the effects of the tax on greed will be very serious and difficult to repair over time.… Mai mult

Increasing energy price - miners' strike brings imports up to 16% of consumption

  Rovinari power plant, part of Complex Energetic Oltenia, closed one of its energy groups on Wednesday night because of the lack of coal, as… Mai mult

A flow of initiatives against compensatory appeal: 188 of detainees released committed robberies, rapes, crimes

USR will file on Monday a bill on repealing the compensation appeals law, based on which thousands of detainees were released from prison before completing… Mai mult

Mugur Isarescu: "Ordinance weird thing" reduces monetary policy efficiency, which will not help Government

The National Bank of Romania (BNR) will convoke the National Committee for Macro-prudential Supervision, where the Ministry of Finance will be required to clarify the… Mai mult

World Bank lowered prospects on Romania's economic growth for 2019 and 2020

  Romania's economy will record an advance of 3.5% in 2019 and 3.1% in 2020, down one percentage point from June 2018 forecast, according to… Mai mult