SIMILAR ARTICLES

Sudden and spectacular deficit growth: budget implementation on H1

  At the end of the first half of the year, the general consolidated budget registered a deficit of about RON 15 billion, an amount… Mai mult

World Bank – A scary report that no longer scares anyone: Latest assessment of Romanian emigration

Between three and five million Romanians work and live abroad. The 2017 UN estimate, rated as optimistic by the World Bank’s Report on Diagnosis of… Mai mult

In only one quarter: Incomes increased five times faster than GDP. For public sector employees, even faster

Data released by the INS for the first quarter of 2018 show that households’ living standards increased considerably compared to the same quarter of the… Mai mult

It is the Administrative Code’s turn: little responsibility for local elected officials, higher power for asset disposing, privileges

The Chamber of Deputies votes the amendments to Romania’s Administrative Code on Monday, amendments that strengthen the political control over local administrations. It is expected… Mai mult

Purchasing power declined for second consecutive month: situation by fields of activity

The average gross wage announced by the INS for May 2018 was 4,512 lei, 0.4% lower than in the previous month. Net nominal average wage… Mai mult

Financial chaos at Finance Ministry: ANAF prepares to reimburse USD 91 million to WB for a reform of which it only implemented 23.5%: nothing for IT systems, everything for consulting services

de Victor Bratu , Răzvan Diaconu 29.1.2018

The Romanian taxpayer’s relationship with the tax administration takes place mainly in the street, not in the virtual space

That is what the Minister of Finance, Mr Ionut Misa, says today, January 23, 2018: The National Agency for Fiscal Administration (ANAF) has not spent anything on the IT system following the implementation of the program in collaboration with the World Bank and all the money spent has been allocated to consulting services. The Minister of Finance’s statement was made at the hearings in the Economic Committee of the Senate.

This is not a joke: it is about USD 91 million. And in 2018, the Romanian Government already starts to reimburse the USD91 million loan contracted with the World Bank and the first instalment of 7.1% of the principal amount is to be paid in October.

In summary: we spent a quarter of the money, the ANAF’s IT system sucks and, perfectly normal, Romania starts to reimburse the loan.

And a reality: if a private company did this way with its loan, it would have gone bankrupt, and the administrator would have been arrested for pushing the firm into insolvency.

The situation, word by word, in detail:

“Unfortunately, this program has been implemented to an extent of 23.5%, which means that 23.5% of the allocated funds has been spent but no penny on the IT system. Absolutely all money, equivalent to RON 60 million, was spent on consulting services only. We had discussions with the World Bank representatives from this point of view. They have notified since 2012, every year, that no progress has been made in the IT system and we limited everything to just make analyses and consultation,” Minister Misa said.

It was not a statement on his own initiative but the answer to a question from one of the committee members who was curious to find out the state of implementation of the ANAF modernization project with the World Bank – an institution that not only constantly notified the Romanian authorities that there is something wrong with this project, but even decided to extend the program for two years, hoping that maybe Romania will do something for the computerization of the system at the European standards.

Out of the nine ministers in charge, eight were from PSD and ALDE

Who are those who, since 2012, mimicked the interest for the reorganization and efficiency? First, the heads of the fiscal administration:

  • Sorin Blejnar – January 6, 2009 – April 17, 2012
  • Serban Pop – April 17, 2012 – April 22, 2013
  • Gelu Stefan Diaconu – April 25, 2013 – February 11, 2016
  • Dragos Doros – March 2016 – January 2017
  • Bogdan Stan – January 13, 2017 – July 18, 2017
  • Mirela Calugareanu – July 2017 – present

Then, those who are officially chiefs of the heads of the fiscal administration – the finance ministers:

  • Florin Georgescu – May 7, 2012 – December 21, 2012
  • Daniel Chitoiu – December 21, 2012 – March 5, 2014
  • Ioana Petrescu – March 5, 2014 – December 14, 2014
  • Darius Bogdan Valcov – December 14, 2014 – March 15, 2015
  • Victor Ponta – March 15, 2015 – March 30, 2015 (interim)
  • Eugen Teodorovici – March 30, 2015 – November 17, 2015
  • Anca Paliu Dragu – November 17, 2015 – January 4, 2017
  • Viorel Stefan – January 4, 2017 – June 29, 2017
  • Ionut Misa – June 2017 – present

The last on the list, Ionut Misa, explained to the committee that he tried something, though:

We had talks with them (World Bank representatives – editor’s note) about the possibility to continue with this formula and, by agreement, we have created the National Fiscal Information Centre. They considered it is a good idea to centralize all ANAF databases and gather the whole IT system under a single umbrella.

There were 322 different databases, many of them written in different programming languages, and it was necessary to unify the whole IT system under one umbrella with a vision and strategy on the IT system for the next period, both on the hardware support, which is obsolete and ANAF made no acquisitions since 2005 from this point of view, as well as on the IT support. We want to avoid any movement of a taxpayer to any other institution that may need such information,” said Minister Ionut Misa.

The statement raises though some problems:

  • this structure was established two months later than the term committed by the Romanian Government
  • the most significant steps towards the unification of the databases and the computerization of the relationship between the taxpayer and the tax authority have the implementation deadline in 2020
  • one of the first tasks set refers to the elaboration of a “unitary strategy for the development and maintenance of the MFP’s IT system”

Translated into common language, the last point means that everything implemented so far will be made again.

And that raises the following question: Who is held responsible for the “23.5%” share representing the money spent – more precisely borrowed from the World Bank – without any practical use?

Important mention: The World Bank – ANAF partnership project costs USD 91 million as a loan. And the loan, according to the initial contract, is to be reimbursed between 2018 and 2025.

The Romanian authorities will pay two instalments per year of 7.1% of the principal amount, starting October 2018 and the last payment will be made in April 2025, according to a contract signed in May 2013 by the Romanian Government and the World Bank officials.

***

Post Scriptum:

cursdeguvernare.ro has been monitoring all during these years the failures of the Ministry of Finance in the digitization and computerization of ANA in line with the standards of a European state and the expectations of the business environment and taxpayers.

Below, you can read the headlines of the signal articles, which failed to make any government react to this situation.

Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 29.1.2018

Lăsați un comentariu


NEWS

Ministry of Finance is drafting a new fiscal framework valid as of January 1, 2019

The Ministry of Public Finance makes a "comparative analysis" of the Tax Code and the Tax Procedure Code with a view to applying a new… Mai mult

Eurostat: Romania and evolution of employee number in public sector in an European context

Romania, Hungary and Slovenia are the member states that recorded the largest increase in the share of public sector employees in the total number of… Mai mult

Fitch confirms Romania's rating at BBB- but warns: fiscal loosening is risky for macroeconomic stability

Fitch Ratings confirmed on Friday Romania's rating for long-term foreign and local currency debt at BBB-, with a stable outlook, but warned that fiscal loosening… Mai mult

"We are working on a tax amnesty mechanism": announcement made by Minister of Finance

Finance Minister Eugen Teodorovici said at a press conference held in Bistrita that "a mechanism of this type is in progress”, a mechanism on tax… Mai mult

AOAR - Economy against new Criminal Code: businessmen denounce excessive protection provided to officials who cause damages to economy

The Businessmen’s Association of Romania (AOAR) asks the ruling coalition to explain the mechanism by which, after changes introduced on Wednesday in the Criminal Code,… Mai mult

Number of insolvencies increased by 12% in first five months. Suspended activities - plus 31%, dissolutions - plus 59%

The increase in the number of companies and PFAs in insolvency was 11.97% in the first five months of this year, compared to the same… Mai mult

Transport infrastructure in Romania needs EUR 70 billion - double as compared to existing resources

The investment needs in Romania's transport infrastructure exceed EUR 70 billion, while the available resources by 2030 are EUR 36 billion, according to the Transport… Mai mult

Refusal to work annuls entitlement to social assistance - bill voted in Chamber of Deputies

Deputies adopted a draft law on Wednesday whereby entitlement to social assistance ceases when a job is refused. The decision, Agerpres announced, was taken with… Mai mult

Subsidy of RON 900/month for employing a graduate based on contracts of indefinite duration

The National Agency for Employment (ANOFM) grants subsidies of RON 900/month to employers who employ graduates of educational institutions, with contracts of indefinite duration, within… Mai mult

C.P. Tariceanu, before the heads of Senates from EU: The European Commission has encouraged the parallel state, in Romania it is like in the 50's

Calin Popescu Tariceanu (foto) delivered a very tough speech on Friday, in the Senate, addressed to the European Commission, which he accused of encouraging the… Mai mult

National Bank of Romania wants to lower indebtedness limit in granting loans to individuals

The National Bank of Romania (BNR) sent to banks for consultation a draft amending Regulation 17/2012, which provides for a consistent lowering of the indebtedness… Mai mult

High impact provisions: Senate has adopted PSD-ALDE amendments to the Code of Criminal Procedure

Senators adopted on Wednesday the draft for amending the Code of Criminal Procedure, by 74 votes for to 28, against. The bill goes to the… Mai mult

RBL: Workforce crisis is worse than economic crisis - 3.4 million Romanians have left the country in last 10 years

Migration is one of the most serious problems facing Romania at this time, along with the lack of infrastructure. However, the return of Romanians to… Mai mult