SIMILAR ARTICLES

Mugur Isarescu: “Ordinance weird thing” reduces monetary policy efficiency, which will not help Government

The National Bank of Romania (BNR) will convoke the National Committee for Macro-prudential Supervision, where the Ministry of Finance will be required to clarify the… Mai mult

World Bank lowered prospects on Romania’s economic growth for 2019 and 2020

  Romania’s economy will record an advance of 3.5% in 2019 and 3.1% in 2020, down one percentage point from June 2018 forecast, according to… Mai mult

Iasi – Tg.Mures highway disappeared from Large Infrastructure Operational Programme 2021-2027

The Ministry of European Funds has taken out Iasi-Tg. Mures highway project from the Large Infrastructure Operational Programme 2021-2027 and the Ministry of Transport already… Mai mult

State is borrowing at increasingly higher costs – government bond yield reached 5.33% per year

The benchmark government bond yield jumped above the 5% threshold on Thursday. The Ministry of Public Finance (MFP) attracted RON 300 million from banks on… Mai mult

Senate postpones discussions on DNA’s request on waiving immunity of Calin Popescu Tariceanu until February 2019

The Senate has decided that it will put to the vote the decision to waive Calin Popescu Tariceanu’s immunity only in the spring session, that… Mai mult

Cronicile

FIC: Amendments on Criminal Codes expose business environment to abuses from civil servants

de Razvan Diaconu , 27.11.2018

Some of the amendments to the criminal codes will generate mistrust regarding Romanian state’s ability to ensure the legality, stability and predictability of business relationships and may expose many companies to an insolvency risk, warns the Foreign Investors Council (FIC).

The warning appears in an open letter addressed to the presidents of the two parliamentary chambers and the Romanian President, a letter containing a list of the main amendments with the potential to seriously affect the business environment.

Possible effects identified by FIC analysis

Negative effects including on the business environment, especially from the perspective of abuses and weakening the mechanism for sanctioning civil servants with whom each professional interacts in their activity.

  • Distrust of the Romanian state’s ability to ensure the legality, stability and predictability of business relationships and overall the business environment.
  • Distrust in the state’s ability to protect the interests of companies and citizens operating in a transparent, fair and professional manner and by complying with legal provisions and commitments assumed.
  • Exposing many companies to a risk of insolvency, as many of those having the position of injured parties in criminal files, who reported on prejudices can be put in the position of being unable to recover the substantial losses, especially caused by corruption offences or offenses in the office. There is the possibility of a civil action in court, but that makes it more difficult to recover damages and equally implies significant costs for the injured party.
  • Limiting the modalities in which the offense is committed to the acts of claiming/receiving/accepting the promise only for some material benefits could have a negative impact in the sense of the impossibility of private companies to prove potential allegations of trafficking of influence in which strictly non-patrimonial benefits have been granted.

Amendments with a direct negative impact on business environment

  • Amendment on Art. 17 Criminal Code – in the new form, crimes committed through omission are decriminalised when there is a contractual obligation to act and the offense exists only when the obligation to act results from the law and not from the contract as well. For example, in a contract in which one party is the state, although the contractual non-enforcement (inaction/omission) may take the form of an abuse of office, the civil servant cannot be held liable because the obligation is only contractual; practically, the possibility of the injured party to file criminal complaints based on the abusive act of a civil servant is eliminated, based on the failure to perform an act that consists of an omission, a liability whose basis is a contractual obligation.
  • Repealing Art. 175 par (2) Criminal Code – the category of assimilated civil servants is eliminated, which unreasonably restricts the sphere of persons who, although they provide services of public interest (notaries, judicial experts, bailiffs, bankers, physicians from the public healthcare system, etc.), under certain conditions, they can no longer be a subject of corruption and office crimes, such as bribery, trade in influence, misappropriation, abuse of office, etc. In certain situations, these professional categories may play a determining role in the management of public money or funds from the general budget of the European Union; therefore, to the extent that entrepreneurs/companies intending to access financing/co-financing sources from such funds for various investment projects would discover potential corruption and/or offenses in office (e.g. bribery, misappropriation, etc.) committed, for example, by bank officials, would no longer have available the means of criminal complaints against them.
  • Amendment on Article 291 (1) Criminal Code – the content of trade of influence offense is modified and it accepted that the offense does not exist if benefits obtained are non-material. The change also makes the existence of trade of influence offense conditional on the promise of trading the influence followed by the intervention before a civil servant. Conditioning the offense on the actual intervention before the public servant considerably restricts the evidence used to prove the offense.
  • Amendment on Art. 297 paragraph (1) Criminal Code – redefines abuse of office crime, which greatly restricts the scope. For example, a civil servant violating the law and providing an undue material benefit to grandchildren, cousins, concubines, or other people can no longer be held responsible for the abuse of office crime. The notion of “material benefits” should continue to include non-patrimonial benefits (e.g. job promotion), all the more so as these acts are at least as common in Romanian criminal practice as material benefits.
  • 17 let. a) Criminal Code (unmodified form) – “the comissive crime involving the occurrence of a result is considered as committed also by omission when: a) there is a legal or contractual obligation to act.” The phrase “contractual obligation” has been deleted, which means a decriminalization of comissive crimes by omission in the event that the obligation to act is not provided for by the law, but only by the contract between the parties.
  • The following conditions are introduced: i) that the abuse of service offense is committed in order to obtain an undue material benefit to themselves, spouse, relatives or in-laws down to second degree, and ii) the loss is certain and effective and higher than the equivalent of a minimum national gross salary. By redefining the abuse of office offense, a substantial partial decriminalisation of this crime is practically made.
  • Similarly, for trade of influence offense, additional conditions are introduced such as i) that the criminal act is committed strictly in order to obtain a material benefit and ii) the promise is followed by the intervention.
  • Regarding the regulation that requires for the case to be closed if no suspect is identified within a year, the FIC claims that it allows and even encourages criminal prosecution bodies to commit abuses. Thus, they may be tempted to artificially attribute the suspect role to persons potentially innocent, the only purpose being to meet the conduct required by law in order to allow further prosecution. In criminal practice, there are many complex causes (e.g. fraudulent money laundering schemes), with a cross-border dimension and a plurality of perpetrators, which hinders the criminal prosecution that involves long-term technical surveillance measures, in order to identify the perpetrators and that makes it virtually impossible to limit this procedural phase to the deadline imposed.
  • To the defendant’s rights section, a new letter is added, lit. (b1), which reads as follows: “the right to be informed of the date and time when the criminal investigation or the hearing conducted by the judge of rights and freedoms takes place”. By introducing this new right, prerequisites are created for irreparably harming criminal prosecution, as the defendant must be aware of the date, hour and place of each criminal prosecution and can participate to them. Consequently, all the criminal prosecution activity will be carried out in the presence of the defendant (including the hearings of injured parties, civil parties, searches or other acts), although current legal provisions give the suspect’s/defendant’s lawyer the right to participate to criminal prosecution. This amendment makes it much harder to obtain evidence.
Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 27.11.2018

Lăsați un comentariu


NEWS

Mugur Isarescu: "Ordinance weird thing" reduces monetary policy efficiency, which will not help Government

The National Bank of Romania (BNR) will convoke the National Committee for Macro-prudential Supervision, where the Ministry of Finance will be required to clarify the… Mai mult

World Bank lowered prospects on Romania's economic growth for 2019 and 2020

  Romania's economy will record an advance of 3.5% in 2019 and 3.1% in 2020, down one percentage point from June 2018 forecast, according to… Mai mult

State is borrowing at increasingly higher costs - government bond yield reached 5.33% per year

The benchmark government bond yield jumped above the 5% threshold on Thursday. The Ministry of Public Finance (MFP) attracted RON 300 million from banks on… Mai mult

Iasi - Tg.Mures highway disappeared from Large Infrastructure Operational Programme 2021-2027

The Ministry of European Funds has taken out Iasi-Tg. Mures highway project from the Large Infrastructure Operational Programme 2021-2027 and the Ministry of Transport already… Mai mult

Senate postpones discussions on DNA’s request on waiving immunity of Calin Popescu Tariceanu until February 2019

The Senate has decided that it will put to the vote the decision to waive Calin Popescu Tariceanu's immunity only in the spring session, that… Mai mult

Implementation of 5G technology, a multiplication effect in economy of EUR 4.7 billion - announces Sorin Grindeanu (ANCOM)

The National Authority for Management and Regulation in Communications (ANCOM) launched on Wednesday the National Strategy for the Implementation of 5G Technologies in Romania for… Mai mult

FIC: Amendments on Criminal Codes expose business environment to abuses from civil servants

Some of the amendments to the criminal codes will generate mistrust regarding Romanian state's ability to ensure the legality, stability and predictability of business relationships… Mai mult

European Semester / European Commission asks Romania to correct its medium-term structural deficit by 1% of GDP

Minister Eugen Teodorovici is pressured by the EU to reduce the budget deficit After finding that the Government has done nothing to adjust the deviation… Mai mult

Sovereign Fund gets legal base. Details announced by Minister Teodorovici

The Government adopted on Thursday the ordinance that provides for the general framework for the establishment of a Sovereign Fund. Later, after new talks with… Mai mult

Ford is looking for 1,700 employees to produce EcoSport SUV model

The representatives of Ford Craiova met on Wednesday with mayors of 30 localities from Dolj county in order to stimulate the attraction of 1,700 new… Mai mult

Development strategy / Government squeezes even investment money from its own companies: EUR 120 million from only two entities in energy field

Nuclearelectrica (SNN) and Romgaz (SNG) have calculated the additional dividends to be paid to the state after the Ministry of Finance (MFP) sent to the… Mai mult

DNA, officially: Senate President is suspected of having received a USD 800,000 bribe. Case file opened at a request from Austrian judicial authorities

The case file in which the DNA requested the waiving of the Senate President’s immunity was opened at the request of Austrian judicial authorities and… Mai mult

Illegal state aid / European Commission demands Romania to recover EUR 60 million from CE Hunedoara

Romania has to recover illegal state aid worth EUR 60 million granted to Compexul Energetic Hunedoara, announced the European Commission with a statement released on… Mai mult

Ministry of Finance planned loans of RON 4.74 billion in November. Costs are increasing

The Ministry of Public Finance (MFP) intends to borrow in November RON 4.74 billion, 1.4% more than in the previous month, according to the Ministry.… Mai mult