Consequences of removing the maximum threshold for CAS and CASS payment. Philosophies about tax in the EU 28

de Victor Bratu | 11.1.2017 .

pensie-300x154Just appointed in office, Grindeanu government implemented the first social measures announced by PSD since the elections, among which the decision that employees will pay pension and healthcare contributions calculated for the total wage, as the current maximum amount equivalent to 5 average gross salaries has been removed.

The decision places Romania into the small group of the EU states whose tax philosophy includes no maximum threshold for pension and healthcare contributions: Denmark, Finland, Sweden, France, Germany, Hungary, Cyprus, and Malta.

This is a measure that will only affect those with monthly gross wage exceeding 14,000 lei.

The matter of principle raised by removing the threshold of five average salaries is that the state taxes without any limit while offering only limited social services.

The only real effect of this decision is that those who are paid this wage will owe higher taxes: according to the Government’s calculations, the measure will bring additional budget revenues of 1.9 billion lei.

It is not sure though that this money will prove enough because Romania should first solve two system “flaws”: the problem of collecting the revenue and the problem of efficiently spending the public money.

Who is affected and how

Statistics of the Ministry of Finance from 2016 shows that in 2015, most of the full-time employees are those with employment contracts with minimum national wage – 33.4% of the employees in Romania.

z

*

  • Full-time employees
  • Gross wage     Number of employees            % of all contracts
  • Removing the maximum threshold affects those with monthly gross wage exceeding 14,000 lei.

*

In terms of salaries, the Ministry’s statistics shows that 0.9% of the employees have gross wages between 10,001 and 15,000 lei and 0.5% of the employees in Romania have wages higher than 15,000 lei.

Since statistics does not offer the exact number of monthly gross wages higher than 14,000 lei, it can be estimated at 50,000 people.

These 50,000 people will, therefore, get less money in the future following the elimination of the maximum threshold of 5 national average gross wages.

But these people will not receive anything for the extra money paid to the state: in practice, those with high salaries use anyway the private healthcare services and contribute to private pension systems.

The fact that 50,000 people are forced by the state to pay higher taxes is likely to theoretically make those with low incomes enjoy.

In reality, neither these people will have any benefit: money taken “from the rich” will go to cover other “gaps” also caused by the Government:

  • CASS exemption for pensioners, voted last week by the members of the Chamber of Deputies
  • The elimination of various taxes decided by the Parliament
  • The increase of the pension point and the minimum pension, etc.

Moreover, we should also recall the annual pension budget deficit of almost EUR4 billion. Following the “liberalized” contributions to CAS, those who now pay higher contributions should equally receive higher pensions in the future.

But looking at the INS statistics on birth rates, given the clear trend of aging population, it becomes obvious that the pension budget cannot sustain in the future the benefits for those who contribute today in an unlimited manner.

Tax philosophies in Europe about contribution to social budgets

Tax systems in Europe are obviously different. Before the latest amendments to the Tax Code adopted by the PSD-ALDE coalition, Romania ranked 14th within the EU 28 in terms of the tax burden for employees and 22nd in terms of tax burden on PFAs.

In 2015, 20 of the 28 EU countries had limited tax levels for social budgets. Among the states imposing social contributions on unlimited income are the Nordic countries (Sweden, Denmark, Finland) and the rich countries Germany and France: social services in these countries are though among the best covering and most efficient and taxpayers know in fact why they pay taxes.

Comparative analysis of the net income of the employees and the PFAs from the EU28 countries, in 2015, by the Fiscal Council:

1-1-768x666

*

  • Average gross income/year   National currency
  • Employee        PFA
  • Social contributions
  • Income tax base
  • Income tax
  • Total tax
  • Net income
  • Ranking in terms of tax burden employee/PFA
  • Click to enlarge

*

Tax systems in the EU28 in 2015 are:

v1

*

  • Income tax rate
  • Average social contribution rate
  • Ranking in terms of total rate of social contribution – employee
  • Ranking in terms of total rate of social contribution – PFA
  • Social contributions (%)
  • Pensions (%)
  • Healthcare (%)
  • Unemployment (%)
  • Other (%)
  • Minimum tax base
  • Annual threshold (national currency)
  • Monthly national average gross wage in local currency (2015)
  • Threshold, as number of average wages in 2015
  • Click to enlarge

*

 

Publicat la data de 11.1.2017 .

Lasa un comentariu


SIMILAR ARTICLES

Siegfried Muresan

Siegfried Muresan / Post-2020 EU budget reform, opportunity or threat

(Siegfried Mureșan is Vice Chair of the Committee on Budgets and Substitute Member in the Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs) The European Union (EU) budget is an investment budget and the predictability of revenue is essential That is why a legitimate question we should ask today is how the EU budget will look after 2020 and whether Brexit will be an opportunity or a threat to ...
Read more »

Victor Bratu

Money for future budget amendment has been found: Army has spent only 8.15% of its endowment budget

The situation of the salary rights in the Ministry of National Defence was the one that officially caused the resignation of Minister Adrian Tutuianu Blocked in the controversy of financial resources available for paying the military wages, various allowances and pensions, the analyses evade another figure that does not look good at all: In the first eight months of the year, the Ministry ...
Read more »

Victor Bratu

What “new Schengen” about which Emmanuel Macron talked in Bucharest will look like: Romania’s calendar of reforms and chances of accession

On the occasion of the French President Emmanuel Macron’s visit in August, the public was informed that Romania has "every right" to ask for the accession to Schengen Area and this will happen but after the area will go through a reform process "I have to be honest, Europe of the Schengen Area is not working well," said President Macron at the Cotroceni Palace, and the idea is unanimously ...
Read more »

Adrian N Ionescu

Romania has the largest current account deficit among emerging EU economies: It is just out of the list

Romania’s current account deficit will be by far the largest of the European Union's emerging economies in 2017 and will exceed 3%, according to the estimates of the banking system The main causes are: a massive increase in imports consequently, the deterioration of the trade balance and government policy of wage increases and tax relief, banking analysts say Romania's current ...
Read more »

Victor Bratu

Data of positive budget rectification: For + 0.04%, they massively cut investments to give salaries and pensions

Finance Minister Ionut Misa presented on Friday some elements of the budget rectification, to be approved by the Government by end of September According to the Finance Minister’s statements, the rectification would be positive (+ 004%), as the official’s explanation is that budgetary revenues are "beyond estimations" That does not mean that all authorities for expenditure will receive ...
Read more »


NEWS

Oracle transfers most of its European hardware support activities to Romania

Oracle, the world’s largest software developer, will transfer most of the European hardware support activities to Romania, to reduce current costs. The process of closing ... Read more

LSE Study: Ten Romanian companies can inspire Europe with their rhythm of growth. Meanings of this selection

London Stock Exchange (LSE) analysts have identified ten Romanian companies among the 1,000 small and mid-sized firms in Europe that can inspire the others with ... Read more

Eastern European countries’ exports of weapons increase. Not Romania’s ones

Producers of bullets, assault weapons, and rockets from former communist countries in Eastern Europe saw a significant increase in orders following the conflicts in the ... Read more

European Commissioner: Brexit will decrease budget for Regional Policy by 10-12%. Member states will have to cover these amounts

The budget allocated by the EU to the Regional Policy will decrease by approximately 10-12% after the exit of the UK from the Union, said ... Read more

Government prepares to guarantee unchanged royalty regime throughout offshore concession contracts

The Government is trying to speed up the implementation of the offshore oil operations. There is a bill at SGG that assures companies having oil ... Read more

Consultations on security topics between Poland, Romania and Turkey with participation of Jens Stoltenberg

Preparations for the NATO Summit in 2018 and the reform of the allied command structures were the main topics for the last week’s meeting, on ... Read more

Representatives of prosecutors across the country reject Minister's proposals to amend justice laws

Representatives of prosecutors from all over the country have rejected amendments to the justice laws proposed by Minister Tudorel Toader, General Prosecutor Augustin Lazar said ... Read more

Average monthly spending per household in 2016: Education - 4 lei, Telephone services - 90 lei

Last year, a household spent a monthly average of 4.05 lei for education, 90.71 lei for telephone services and 26.26 lei for health services, according ... Read more

Cost of state indebtedness rises and drags euro exchange rate with it

Government’s hunger for money causes a growing demand on the market, which increases the borrowing cost for the state and encourages distrust in the national ... Read more

Mihai Tudose about royalties: A new law to enter into force on January 1, 2018; royalty level will "depend on companies’ behaviour" in terms of prices pushed by the new excise duty

Prime Minister Mihai Tudose has announced the date of January 1, 2018, as a “certain” term for the entry into force of a long-delayed new ... Read more

File / Share of French investments in Romanian industry decreased compared to 2007. Investment in agriculture and utilities increased

The share of direct investment (FDI) made by French companies in the Romanian industry fell from 56% of total French FDI in 2007 to 46% ... Read more

Prime Minister Mihai Tudose - threats and warnings to banks and oil companies: Romantic period has passed

Prime Minister Mihai Tudose has released several strong signals to banks and oil companies. He says that he is willing to take major risks in ... Read more

MApN states its availability to buy US attack helicopters

Defence Minister Adrian Tutuianu has signed on Wednesday a letter of intent on price and availability regarding the purchase of attack helicopters produced by Bell ... Read more

Minister Ionut Misa: Salary growth to increase public pension fund deficit by 22% in 2018 compared to 2017

The deficit of the public pension fund would be 17.2 billion lei in 2018, up 22% from 14.1 billion lei this year because of the ... Read more

Romania - world champion of frontier markets in 2017, by return on stock exchange investment

Evolution of BET-TR since the beginning of the year The Romanian capital market had the highest growth among all 23 countries in the portfolio of ... Read more

Chinese have obtained Romania's consent to take over former Rompetrol Group. Romanian-Kazakh investment fund remains just a paper

Romanian authorities have agreed on the deal by which China Energy Company Limited (CEFC) took over 51% of the KazMunayGas International shares (KMGI, former Rompetrol ... Read more

Finance Ministry - officially: Yes, social contributions will be transferred from employer to employee but net salaries will not decrease

Social contributions will be entirely transferred to the employee as of January 1, 2018 – the Ministry of Finance announces in a press release. Despite ... Read more

Finally: Romania has officially discovered that nine out of 29 analysed food products have a lower quality than those from Western Europe

Photo: Digi24 Nine of the 29 Romanian food products analysed have a different content than the identical goods brought from shops from Belgium, Germany and ... Read more

Eurostat: Romania had second highest budget deficit in EU in Q1 /2017. Reaction of Finance Ministry

Romania’s seasonally adjusted budget deficit was 3.2% of GDP in the first quarter of 2017. It was the second highest budget deficit in the European ... Read more

Government borrows one billion euros to co-finance large infrastructure projects

The Ministry of Finance (MFP) has contracted a loan of one billion euros with the European Investment Bank (EIB) to cover the state budget contribution, ... Read more

A set of measures proposed by AOAR to Government to improve business environment in Romania

After a period when all major business organizations – Romanian and foreign – have rejected the tax experiments especially those proposed by the Mihai Tudose ... Read more

BNR: Romanian public administrations have financial commitments amounting to 45% of GDP

The share of financial commitments by public administrations remained, between 2015 and Q1 2017, at the same level of 45.2% of GDP, according to the ... Read more

National Centre of Financial Information, which will gather tax databases, is established

The National Centre of Financial Information “will be established by 1 September 2017 within the central office of the Ministry of Public Finance, by merging ... Read more