85% (!) Increase in current account deficit in 2017: Short-term debt increases, foreign investment stagnates

The current account of the balance of payments recorded a deficit of EUR 6.464 billion last year, 85% higher than in 2016. The minus registered… Mai mult

Inflation reached 4.32% in first month of 2018. Explanations and what is to be expected

Romania recorded a 0.78% price increase in the first month of the year compared to the previous month, which led to an inflation rate of… Mai mult

Reform in ANAF has stalled. World Bank: There is no political commitment to reforms

Romanian taxpayers waiting for ANAF reform The World Bank found that ANAF’s modernization process stalled immediately after the first stage of the acquisition of the… Mai mult

Research domain: if private sector does not finance it, state does not stimulate it. A few comparisons with other countries from East being in this suffering

Romania ranked last year second to last among the EU member states in terms of R&D expenditure as a share of GDP. With only 0.48%,… Mai mult

Romania – highest financing costs among ECE states: prospects of vulnerability increase and accentuation

  The financing costs of Romania and Hungary have increased, while costs of other Central European countries have maintained steady in the last week –… Mai mult

Average income trap – danger for Romania and CEE states: Setting growth engine on innovation is the only solution          

de Mariana Bechir , 12.2.2018

In the absence of strategies to increase technological levels and raise wages, Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) will remain in the average income trap without any prospect of closing the gap with the West, warns Martin Myant, senior researcher at the European Union Trade Institute (ETUI).

The analysis takes into account the countries of the Visegrad Group 4 plus Romania (which comes from an inferior level but had similar economic growth).

In the 27 years of transition, these countries have developed economies dependent on foreign capital, where the main engine was the foreign direct investment (FDI) attracted by cheap labour.

This model has reached its limits and active state policies are required to stimulate a new structure of the economy.

That is why strategies with a two-directional impact should be developed, in Martin Myant’s opinion:

  • to influence the type of foreign investment that will be made (to stimulate FDI for high added-value industries)
  • to encourage autochthonous autonomous development to surpass the technological level of multinationals present in these countries

Dependence on foreign direct investment (FDI)

The first significant foreign investments came in the early and mid-90s when companies from abroad participated in privatizations started in the five states.

In all these countries, the peak moment (the year when FDI reached the largest share of GDP) was reached before 2008, the year that marks the slowdown in foreign capital inflows.

The pioneer was Hungary, where foreign direct investment accounted for 10.3% of GDP in 1995, a percentage reflecting the government’s preference to privatize companies by selling them to multinationals.

In the case of Poland, it is noticed that it was initially much more reluctant to accept foreign companies, and Romania is the last one to reach the maximum FDI/GDP (in 2006).

Between 2009 and 2016, Romania had the highest annual average – 2% of GDP, followed by Hungary, where the share was 1.9%:

In all cases, EU accession has not influenced the process, with multinationals anticipating it and having massive investments before. It can be seen even in the case of Romania, where the peak was reached in 2006.

The exception is the Czech Republic, where the highest FDI share of GDP was recorded in 2005.

Romania’s case – the worst

Foreign companies have become the major exporters in these countries and this way brought additional benefits. The main sectors where investments have been made are electronics and the automotive industry:

Over time, though, the positive effect of FDI has diminished and tends to be eliminated, as evidenced by the reduced impact of FDI in 2014 on the foreign balance (Romania is missing):

Romania, with even lower salaries than in the other four states, is a slightly different case than Visegrad 4 – here it has been relocated the production of goods for which factors such as highly qualified workforce or Western proximity matter less.

That is why Romania has come to dominate the car wiring sector. The volume of exports of such products has surpassed in time the Czech Republic (in 2001) and even Germany (in 2006).

The production of these wiring systems is the most mobile – they are relatively simple to do, do not require highly qualified personnel, infrastructure or significant investments, so that the activity can be quickly relocated to countries with cheap labour.

This phenomenon even took place in the region, with closures of production in the Czech Republic and relocations to Romania.

The data that Martin Myant analyses show that the price per kilogram of such product exported from the Czech Republic and Romania is below the one from Germany (although the quality is the same) and even decreased as the export volume increased:

Multinationals have transferred to a much lesser extent the types of production that require a high number of highly qualified workers and complex activities (such as research and development) are not expected to be moved to the CEE in the future.

For political and image related reasons, these will be maintained in Western states.

The consequence is that this type of dependency creates limits for the convergence process, does not ensure the progress towards a competitive economy (from a complementary one where we are now) and even threatens the stability of CEE economies (by increasing the risk of relocating the production to countries with lower wages).

Conclusion: Full wage convergence of the salaries can only be achieved if the income increases is accompanied by measures to create high value-added economic activity.

For this, there is a need for the state to take a strategic role to boost investment in skills, education and research so that we can reach an innovation-based growth.

Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 12.2.2018

Lăsați un comentariu


"SOS" letters sent by business community to state institutions: Reform ANAF!

The member organizations of the Coalition for Romania's Development (CDR) urge the Government that the reform of ANAF should become one of the "top" priorities… Mai mult

Government has approved procedure for acquiring four multifunctional corvettes built in Romania and asks US Government to sell long-range ballistic missile to it

Romanian Government approved Thursday two decisions on the national endowment programs - "Multifunctional corvette" program and "Multiple long-range ballistic missile launcher system" - HIMARS. According to… Mai mult

Transgaz to participate in Eastring gas pipeline along with Slovak counterpart Eustream

The operator of the national natural gas pipeline Transgaz (TGN) and Eustream, its Slovak counterpart, signed a memorandum of understanding "to investigate the opportunities to… Mai mult

AOAR: Solutions to imbalances produced by chaotic tax legislation - business environment reaction to a slander from a minister

The Businessmen's Association of Romania (AOAR) proposes a series of solutions to get out of the "chaos" of the fiscal and revenue legislation adopted last… Mai mult

Government has approved OUG to preserve income of IT and part-time employees

The Government approved on Thursday the OUG comprising the measures needed to preserve net wages that professional groups exempted from income tax and part-time employees… Mai mult

EBRD: Romania needs to change its economic growth model. Better "sooner than later"

Romania needs to adopt a different economic model if it wants to avoid a crisis caused by the current consumption boom, according to Matteo Patrone,… Mai mult

INS - Context survey: stability or even stagnation, employees about the same but all prices up!

According to the perception of managers from the field, the manufacturing industry will register a relative stability of production volume in the following months (conjuncture… Mai mult

Romanian Business Leaders: List of "signs of distrust" in economic year 2018

The Romanian Business Leaders (RBL) Macroeconomic Confidence Index, of 52.3 points, shows that the entrepreneurs and executives from the most important businesses in Romania have… Mai mult

OLAF runs investigation at Metrorex - possible overpriced payments at Metro Line 5

UPDATE: In a statement issued to RFI, OLAF confirmed the investigation at Metrorex, and its topic - the Metro Line 5 (M5) financed by European… Mai mult

Government goes on Eurobond market and attracts over EUR 3 billion. Complicated yields

The Ministry of Finance is trying to take advantage of the still favourable conditions for emerging government securities and goes on the Eurobonds market with… Mai mult

MFP: Government will borrow RON 74 billion in 2018, only through government bonds

The total volume of loans planned by the Ministry of Finance (MFP) for 2018 amounts to about RON 74 billion. Loans are to be secured… Mai mult

Pessimistic expectations about the future in latest CFA Romania research - economists anticipate a decrease of personal incomes and continuous depreciation of Romanian leu

In December 2017, the macroeconomic confidence indicator of CFA Romania declined to 41 points, the lowest value since April 2013, by 3.1 points below the… Mai mult

Second largest bank in EU, BNP Paribas, opens its branch in Bucharest

BNP Paribas, the largest French bank and the second largest in the EU by the size of assets, will launch its retail operations in Romania… Mai mult

Three options by which BNR intends to moderate lending

The BNR will impose restrictions on credits to the population, to anticipate potential non-payment risks. This could happen in March if the project is approved… Mai mult

Siegfried Muresan: Amendments to Romanian laws on judicial will be discussed in European Parliament

The European Parliament will run debates on the situation of justice in Romania in the next plenary session, in February, in the Strasbourg plenary. The… Mai mult