A table: Distressing image of Romanian agriculture. Few and poor farms: a comparison with Europe

de Marin Pana | 31.12.2016 .

 

agricultura-tractor-300x203The ratio between the standard income obtained by a farm from the Netherlands and a farm from Romania is 92 to 1, according to the Eurostat data. They would have an average of 303,760 euros, while we would have only 3,303 euros.

To keep in mind, this average level also includes large farms, in which case the ratio drops to less than 4 to 1, with 4,101,551 euros for the Dutch and 1,104,177 euros for us.

The explanation is simple and devastating for the gap that we should recover. In their case, the fifth of the agricultural production from the poorest farms is at an average of 87,451 euros per year, while in our case it is a tiny amount of 856 euros because production is primarily intended for self-consumption and not for the market.

Below, a report about the relationship between large and small farms, valid for 2015:

tabel

*

Revenues (euros/ year)

Country           Average          Poor farms      Large farms    Number of poor/large farms

*

Property fragmentation has played the key role. Romania holds slightly more than a third of the number of farms from the EU (33.5%), followed at a big distance by Poland (13.2%).

This is the situation although we rank the sixth, with only 7.5% representing the utilised agricultural land, after France (15.9%), Spain (13.3%), the UK (9.9%), Germany (9.6 %) and, again, Poland (8.3%).

Classification of farms according to Eurostat:

Classification of farms into five categories by the economic volume (value of annual production, in euros):

  • Very small farms under 2,000 euros
  • Small farms 2000-7999 euro
  • Medium farms 8000-24999 euro
  • Large farms 25000-99999 euro
  • Very large farms at least 100,000 euros

Classification into small and large farms by the total revenue obtained.

The small ones are those of smallest sizes that obtained 20% of total production. The largest are those that have the highest achieved all sizes and 20% of total production. Note: according to this criterion, definitions differ from country to country but the sizes of small and large farms at the national level are relevant.

Classification of farms into four categories by the size (area in hectares):

  • Very small farms under 2 hectares
  • Small farms at least 2, but less than 20 hectares
  • Farms average at least 20, but less than 100 hectares
  • Large farms over 100 hectares

Poor structure of farms by surface

Small and very small farms (under 20 hectares) represent over 95% in five EU member states. Along with us (it was expected to fall in this category), in the same category we find Slovenia, Malta, Greece and Cyprus, but when they make a more detailed analysis, Eurostat records that more than half of the very small farms (less than 2 hectares) are in Romania, 54.4% respectively.

Obviously, at the other end, we are among the seven EU member states (along with the same above mentioned countries, plus Croatia and Poland) where the number of large farms is less than 1% of the total. To get the picture of the distance that separates us from the developed West, we mention that this number exceeds 20% of the total in four states (the UK, Luxembourg, France and Denmark).

Moreover, farms with areas larger than 100 hectares cumulated, in 2013, 52.1% of the EU utilised agricultural land, following a quite clear process of concentration (they represented only 45.2% in 2005). This matter also concerns the former socialist countries, including the Czech Republic that became the leader in terms of average size of the farm in the EU, with 133 hectares, surpassing the UK (only 93.6 hectares).

Here we find the key to the effective shift from feudalism, with the society characterized by the majority of self-consumption, without extensive relationships of the employed and taxed workforce, and capitalism, in which what matters is production for the market with the work of employees like those from industrial enterprises.

And here we find the model to follow for Romania. The countries that have changed the fastest their structure of agricultural production, took the model of industrial exploitation and headed toward the practice from the developed West are the Czech Republic and Slovakia, the only EU countries that have more than two-thirds of the agricultural workforce employed on the large farms.

Incidentally, in a manual of military geography from the third decade of the last century, Czechoslovakia was already presented as an industrial-agrarian economy and not the other way around. Along with Germany and Sweden, which shows that processes are slower at the historical level, but also settle. We went after 1989 all the way back where we were before, but apparently, that was not the best idea.

Therefore, it is no surprise that the countries from the Central Europe are more capitalist than us and have a higher work productivity at the national level. It might even appear the suspicion of what sets us apart from them and penalizes us both in terms of GDP / capita and revenues.

Accordingly, a relatively large number of people who are not integrated, but marginally into the market that subsists, not exists, economically speaking. If we calculate the national average of our “Czechs and Slovaks” from all the other economic sectors and the farmers lost in time on our homeland we might rapidly explain why we are at only three-quarters of the Czech-Slovak standard of living.

Hope comes from the dynamism that we can bring. Surprisingly, although it has one of the most aging workforces in agriculture, Romania has at the same time the highest proportion of managers under 35 working in large farms among the EU countries (57.3%, about six times more than the EU average!). It remains for the authorities to support the transformation of a major deficiency into a development opportunity.

Publicat la data de 31.12.2016 .

Lasa un comentariu


SIMILAR ARTICLES

Victor Bratu

Why Romania fails to join OECD: criteria that it does not meet and what to do

Romania's accession to the OECD is a major goal of the Romanian foreign policy since 2004 After 7 governments at Victoria Palace and 13 years since establishing this objective, during which the OECD has received new members 2 times (2004 and 2012), Romania is still waiting for a favourable decision According to an OECD report issued in December 2016, the wait seems to be lasting and does ...
Read more »

Adrian N Ionescu

Royalties on resources – negotiations and draft proposals

The management of the inter-ministerial committee in charge of drafting the legislation on royalties has been taken over by the Ministry of Economy from the Ministry of Finance (MFP) said on Wednesday Ionut Misa, Ministry of Finance State Secretary, quoted by Agerpres "All players remain at the table” I cannot give any definite date (regarding the completion of the new law that will ...
Read more »

Marin Pana

Congenital anomalies of Romania’s Consolidated General Budget

Having summarised the state budget revenue and expenditure (BS), let us see how they integrate into the consolidated general budget (BGC), of which they represent about a half and where they add to the amounts from the local budgets, the social security budget, the insurance budget for unemployment, the national health insurance fund, etc Minority revenue, majority spending Official data show ...
Read more »

Marin Pana

Budget and spendings of Romanian households: comparison with the EU countries. Some suggestions for redirection of money

Romania ranks first in the European Union in terms of share of spending for food in the household budgets and ranks last in three categories of expenses: clothing and footwear, catering and insurance, according to the data of Eurostat, the statistical office of the EU The shares of the various categories of expenditure, organized by the EU norms in 12 groups of goods and services are those ...
Read more »

Marin Pana

Expenditure from 2017 budget: Sudden turn towards underdevelopment

  The expenditure from the 2017 state budget has been planned with an increase almost three times higher than the economic growth foreseen in the draft budget (certain 149% by law, against an economic growth forecast, debatable, of 52%), which could not bode well for the chances to implement the provisions of the state budget Some milestones to be considered It remains quite unclear how ...
Read more »


NEWS

World Bank, interested to support founding of Sovereign Investment Fund

Alexandru Petrescu, Minister of Economy The World Bank is interested in the announcement that Romania plans to establish a Sovereign Fund for Development and Investment ... Read more

Memorandum: Sovereign Fund to be financed from selling shares of state companies and bonds

To obtain financing, the Sovereign Fund for Development and Investment (FSDI) planned by the Government will sell shares in the state companies received in its ... Read more

Law on hypermarkets / European Commission launched infringement procedures against Romania and Hungary

The European Commission started on Wednesday the infringement procedure against Romania and Hungary on the matter of retail of agricultural and food products. More specifically, it ... Read more

Romania, referred to CJEU over illegal landfills. EC asks Bucharest to allow Bulgarians to have equal access to fish from Black Sea

The European Commission has decided to bring Romania in The Court of Justice of the European Union because the country has not closed and rehabilitated ... Read more

Forest Stewardship Council permanently withdrew certification for wood processed by Schweighofer

The international organization Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) announced Friday in a press release that permanently withdraws the certification for the wood processed by Austrian group ... Read more

Historical demographic records in 2016: Lowest number of live births after 1876 and largest negative natural growth in history

The natural growth was negative in December 2016, as the number of deaths surpassed the live births by 9,782 people. The data for the entire ... Read more

BNR forecasts lower economic growth than Government. Explanation: different "macroeconomic model"

The National Bank of Romania (BNR) forecasts the economic growth between 4% and 5% in 2017, based on its macroeconomic model; its estimation would have ... Read more

Government amends, only 3 months after last change, the method of approving price of medicines. Industry claims 48% of the market is disrupted

The Ministry of Health has launched to public debate a government decision draft to amend the calculation methodology and the endorsement/approval procedure for the maximal ... Read more

EIU: Economic growth may slow down to 3.6% in 2017, while budget deficit could reach 3.3% of GDP. Other estimates

Romania might register in 2017 an economic growth slowdown to 3.6% from the 2016 estimate of 5%, and a budget deficit of 3.3% based on the ... Read more

Klaus Iohannis in Parliament: Legislate for Romania not for some politicians with problems. Do what you promised during elections, do not make fun

President Klaus Iohannis assured on Tuesday that he does not intend to change in any way the result of the parliamentary elections, asking instead for ... Read more

Four largest universities and Ad Astra Association: Government reorganizes, namely re-politicises research domain

  The Minister of Research prepares the “reorganization of the advisory bodies” under the authority of the ministry, which risks to undo “any effort made ... Read more

A new phenomenon: brands’ revolt. How advertising decreased on Romania TV and Antena 3 news channels because of tendentious reporting on protests against Government

Against the background of protests caused by the Government’s initiative to amend the Criminal Code by emergency ordinance and the call of Frontline Club for ... Read more

Government becomes more powerful than Parliament. When reality is entitled to contradict Constitutional Court

  Romania’s Constitutional Court ruled Wednesday, 8 February, following the examination of the request received from President Klaus Iohannis, that there is no constitutional conflict ... Read more

Head of Joint Standing Committee for Exercise of Parliamentary Control over Romanian Intelligent Service asks for investigations on multinationals who allegedly urged employees to attend protests. IPP calls for his resignation

Senator Adrian Tutuianu (PSD), Chairman of the Joint Standing Committee for the Exercise of Parliamentary Control over the Activity of the Romanian Intelligent Service (SRI), ... Read more

DNA is investigating how the two ordinances have been drafted. Tough reaction of Ministry of Justice

  UPDATE 13.30: DNA confirmed, adding that it is only about procedural acts carried out following a complaint, as required by law. If the act ... Read more

Upgrade in financing for Romania: Without listing Hidroelectrica, promoting Romanian capital market to emerging market status faces further waiting time

The Romanian capital market needs to meet only one more criterion, out of nine, in order to be promoted from frontier market to emerging market ... Read more

Power, in an image: Mr Liviu Dragnea & Sorin

The press conference organized on Thursday by Liviu Dragnea and Prime Minister Sorin Grindeanu provided, besides the explanations that the two officials offered about the ... Read more

Mysterious change in Romanian energy price: The most expensive MWh in Europe for production exceeding national consumption

Romania recorded on 15 and 23 January 2017 the highest energy prices in Europe, reaching 74.92 euros per MWh, respectively 96.52 euros per MWh, according ... Read more

Minister of Economy: Royalties should have a correct level from regional perspective, for different types of resources

The Ministry of Economy and Energy is currently working on a new system of royalties, to allow investors’ access to a clear list of all ... Read more

Liviu Voinea (BNR): State’s financing needs amount 9% of GDP this year

The country’s financing needs for this year is around 9% of GDP, which is sustainable, given that “Romania has a good macroeconomic image,” said Wednesday ... Read more

Romanian Investors Employer Association asks for predictable government policies

Romanian Investors Employer Association (PIAROM) sends the message to the Government that understands the rationale of eliminating the 5-salary threshold for CAS and CASS, but ... Read more

Expanding domestic capital: Bitdefender and Dedeman increase their business scale by new acquisitions

Companies with Romanian capital surprise by spectacular actions that previously were rather typical to the foreign capital: Bitdefender took over a partner company from the ... Read more

Liquidity of Romanian banking system - the lowest from Central and Eastern Europe, relative to GDP

The excess liquidity of the Romanian banking system was 4.5 billion lei in December, or 1.3% of GDP, excepting the minimum reserve holdings from the ... Read more