SIMILAR ARTICLES

Real convergence – Wage purchasing power: Some comparisons with former communist countries

BNR made a thorough analysis of Romania’s status in terms of real convergence with Western economies. A precondition for adopting the euro, in line with… Mai mult

Eurozone accession in mid-term – single objective that can limit slippages in economy

Keeping the national currency under a controlled float exchange is a way to optimize the sustainable economic growth towards getting closer to the West but… Mai mult

Natural gas prices for Romanians: proportion of taxes, third largest in EU

The largest share of taxes in the natural gas price structure for households has been recorded in Denmark (55% of the price), the Netherlands (53%),… Mai mult

2018 budget – official draft: Ministry of Finance counts on a 5.5% increase and an exchange rate of 4.55 lei/euro. Prime Minister Tudose has doubts

The state budget for 2018 drafted by the Ministry of Public Finance (MPF) counts on a decline in the economic growth only to 5.5% in… Mai mult

European Semester 2018: Romania follows a pro-cyclical fiscal policy, structural deficit went up to 2.3%, compared to MTO target of 1%

The European Commission (EC) has determined that Romania has not taken efficient measures to “correct its significant deviation from the adjustment plan to achieve the… Mai mult

10 years of EU / Devastating income inequality: exceeding the level recorded at the time of accession and the highest within the Union. Inequality in UE28

de Marin Pana 11.1.2017

societateSomewhat paradoxically, the unequal distribution of income in Romania decreased during the crisis and returned in 2015 to a higher level than at the time of joining the European Union. In other words, the benefits of resuming the economic growth and recovering the GDP above the 2008 level have been mostly awarded to a small segment of the population, which largely explains the growing social tensions.

The ratio between the share of total incomes that goes to the 20% of the population with the highest incomes and the share of total revenue going to the 20% of the population with the lowest incomes (it should be understood as equivalised disposable income) was 8.1 in the first year of EU membership. Simply put, the richest Romanians gained about eight times more than the poorest fellow Romanians.

How relation between rich and poor developed

To note, 2007 was the first year when this indicator has been calculated based on the European methodology, to ensure comparability to other countries. The indicator fell to 6.1 in 2010, when the effects of the economic crisis were most intense, then it went increasingly faster back to higher levels. Consequently, it reached 8.3 in 2015, higher than in 2007 and the highest within the European Union.

tabel1-3-e1483965236383

*

  • Year
  • Income of rich/poor

*

If position ourselves within the European context, we can see that things are even worse than would seem at the first glance. Despite the devastating income ratio, clear cause of damage to social cohesion, Romania is NOT the country where the richest get most of the benefits, but the country where poorest get the least of the economic activity results.

Lithuania has a share of 44.4% allocated to the rich, compared to 42.3% in our case, a level that is anyway well above the EU average of 38.8%. At the other end, we are unfortunately the EU red flashlight, with a share of only 5.1% of incomes going to the poorest fifth of the population.

Average and extreme cases in the EU in terms of income inequality:

tabel2-1

*

  • The richest 20%          Average EU28            Lithuania          Slovenia
  • The poorest 20%        Average EU28            Romania         the Czech Republic
  • Source: Eurostat, Figures for the Future, 2016 edition

*

If we refer to the 57% standard of living in Romania compared to the EU average and compare the values above against the national average, we obtain a social configuration with one fifth of Romanians, with the highest income, is at 120% of the EU average and the other fifth lives at around 14.5% of that average.

How we are doing compared to other countries from the Union

The data are briefly presented below for some countries, according to the Eurostat reports for 2007, 2010 and 2015, with the idea to compare us with other countries having a similar level of development and the major Western democracies. It shows quite clearly that we are well off the European practice, be it central or Western. Besides, we are doing even worse in terms of income inequality than our slightly poorer neighbours from the South of Danube.

tabel3

*

  • Income rate between rich and poor

*

As a model to follow, as in other cases related to the economy, we would also take the Polish model. An example that developed independently of the crisis and steadily adjusted to Germany’s practice, which it almost reached last year. On the Latin branch, though, we are more like Spain or Italy (of course, on different levels of economic performance redistribution, despite our socialist past and their capitalist past), countries where inequality has deepened over the recent years.

As for the Czech-Slovak moderation and consistency, it is very unlikely for us to ever reach such ratio in terms of income between the richest and the neediest citizens. Incidentally, just a way of saying, from the Romanian perspective, by excluding Bucharest-Ilfov region, the other regions have people about as wealthy as the poorest 20% of the Czechs.

Paradox: Inequality decreased during the right-wing governments and grew during left-wing ones

Chances to Europeanize the redistribution of the economic results are minimal as neither from a political perspective is it seen any correlation with the ideology encouraged in theory. Here, over the ten years of EU membership (for a variety of reasons), inequality declined during the so-called right-wing governments and rose back exactly when left-wing declared governments ruled.

The problem is that before bringing the convergence of living standards to 60% or 75% of the EU average, we should do something to no longer have the devastating ratio between the richest and poorest at a level almost double compared to the European good practice. Including in terms of euro adoption, as we cannot join the Eurozone with such a South American like living standards gap between citizens.

Mergeți în homepage ›

Publicat la data de 11.1.2017

Lăsați un comentariu


NEWS

British Vitruvian Partners bought 30% of Bitdefender

Vitruvian Partners investment fund acquired about 30% of Bitdefender from Axxess Capital and becomes the second largest shareholder in the company, valued at over USD… Mai mult

Split VAT at the Chamber of Deputies: Dilemmas of all kinds. Thresholds for outstanding payments have increased 10 times, Budget Committee to resume debates on Monday

The Budget Committee of the Chamber of Deputies has increased ten times the threshold of the outstanding VAT obligations from which companies will automatically be… Mai mult

Competition Council: Food price increase could be caused by demand excess from budget deficit

The Competition Council started an analysis, following the request of the Ministry of Agriculture, to establish the causes of the accelerated food price increase this… Mai mult

Seizure of all Liviu Dragnea's assets to recover EUR 28 million in Tel Drum case

Liviu Dragnea at the exit of the DNA headquarters where he was expected by a group of supporters and another of protesters. DNA prosecutors have… Mai mult

Rompetrol saga, chapter about money: Government asks KazMunaiGaz to pay the historical debt and demand settlement of case in court

The extension of the memorandum between the Romanian state and KazMunaiGaz, the owner of the Rompetrol Group, will be discussed only after the company's historical… Mai mult

"Not only we have not died, we rank third in the world" - Government approved second budget amendment, deficit of 2.96% of GDP

The second budget amendment this year has been adopted at the government meeting on Wednesday. As the Finance Minister assures, this amendment is "positive", the… Mai mult

Mayors: Government to offset by state budget money municipalities’ losses following tax measures

Mayors accepted on Tuesday in the negotiations with Prime Minister Mihai Tudose and several cabinet members, the promises made by the government officials to partially… Mai mult

Competition Council, "worried" that municipalities are establishing their own companies

The establishment of own companies by local administration to manage the services at the local level is worrying for the competition authority, Bogdan Chiritoiu, President… Mai mult

Draft legislation on judicial system in Parliament – to be debated as a matter of emergency

The ruling coalition registered with the Chamber of Deputies on Tuesday the draft amendments to the three important laws for the judicial system: Law 303/2004… Mai mult

Negative opinion and analysis of Fiscal Council on tax changes. "Tax package" costs 5.2 billion, not planned at all

The Fiscal Council issued a negative opinion on the proposal to amend the Fiscal Code, according to the opinion published Friday on the institution’s website.… Mai mult

Negative opinion from CES for Tax Code changes, Government meeting postponed

The Economic and Social Council, a consultative body of the Parliament and the Romanian Government, issued a negative opinion on Tudose cabinet's draft amendment to… Mai mult

Doing Business 2018: It is easier to do business in Republic of Moldova than in Romania

Romania ranks 45th in the Doing Business 2018 ranking by the World Bank (WB), with a total score of 72.87 points, right under the Republic… Mai mult

Ministry of Finance assures that 2017 target deficit, namely 2.96% of GDP, is not at risk

Regarding the EUROSTAT release on Romania’s budget deficit in the second quarter of 2017, the Ministry of Public Finance (MFP) has issued a press release… Mai mult

Trade Winds: US broadens economic cooperation base with Romania: most US companies coming to Bucharest are SMEs

SMEs are the most numerous among the over 100 American companies participating in the Trade Winds mission launched in Bucharest by the US Department of… Mai mult

Transgaz borrows EUR 50 million from EIB to finance BRUA pipeline

  Shareholders of Transgaz national gas carrier will provide information on the conclusion of an EUR 50 million loan agreement with the European Investment Bank… Mai mult